News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:VCard and RSS as an alternative to social media by iathan on Saturday March 23, 2024 @03:27AM (#39798149)
Nothing new here. That was the original idea of the (open) semantic web. Failed miserably as all social media companies lock in their customers. Technical solutions have been there for decades. They don’t fit the business model.
Re:VCard and RSS as an alternative to social media by RandomGuy456 on Saturday March 23, 2024 @04:37AM (#39798404)
If you were just to follow the business model you would end up trap in a situation where big corporations control your social online identity, your goverments and pretty much very inch of exploitable sea and land.

I like the idea of falling miserably over and over again.

Re:VCard and RSS as an alternative to social media by addicted on Saturday March 23, 2024 @07:49AM (#39799225)
That’s the point though.

The technical solutions exist. We need to do better at figuring out how to beat the power of the business model.

The hundreds of billions of dollars that the current lock-in of corporate social media brings in is a powerful tool that companies use to keep better solutions inaccessible to most people.

The other tool they use is the massive use of dark patterns and armies of phds whose only purpose is to keep you hooked onto the product they offer. Like a super drug whose mechanisms can be tailored at an individual level to maximize addiction.

Re:VCard and RSS as an alternative to social media by RandomGuy456 on Saturday March 23, 2024 @10:12AM (#39800056)
Word
Re:VCard and RSS as an alternative to social media by ivan_gammel on Saturday March 23, 2024 @09:49AM (#39799928)
It failed miserably because of poor UX, not business model. Social media conglomerates capitalize on integrated UX and use the power of it to fuel their business models. They do not really lock in their customers the way SaaS vendors do: before I left social media, I had at least 3 or 4 replicas of my social graph, overlapping by at least 80%. Users can move between platforms if there’s any value in it.
Re:VCard and RSS as an alternative to social media by sham1 on Tuesday March 26, 2024 @01:27AM (#39824510)
There's nothing in here that would technically preclude one from building a nice UI around this and make this have a nice UX where most people wouldn't even need to know that any given protocol like this is being used.

The social media conglomerates would have been able to figure it out instead of building their own proprietary systems for this stuff, if they had wanted to. But, well, they didn't want to.

Re:VCard and RSS as an alternative to social media by ivan_gammel on Tuesday March 26, 2024 @06:11AM (#39826021)
> There's nothing in here that would technically preclude one from building a nice UI around this and make this have a nice UX

If it were so easy, we would see it already - there’s sufficient demand for this kind of solution. Engineers and STEM graduates in general often fail to understand that technology isn’t always the main constraint. There are harder problems in the world to solve, that actually define the experience. It’s people, it’s regulations and liabilities, it’s financial planning and outcomes etc etc. There exists a technology for many wonderful things, yet we don’t see them and it is not corporations to blame.