Re:Nokia Tells Reddit It Infringes Some Patents in Lead-Up t...
by Gormo on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @12:06PM
(#39757171)
> IP is not property, and empirical evindence shows they do more harm then good for humanity.
Although I agree with your position re IP not legitimately being property, I want to nitpick a bit here, and point out that empirical evidence can only substantiate empirical claims. Construing outcomes as "harm" or "good" is a normative evaluation, so this argument is an attempt to leap across the is-ought gap.
Re:Nokia Tells Reddit It Infringes Some Patents in Lead-Up t...
by aaa_aaa on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @01:55PM
(#39758483)
Reason I mentioned empirical evidence is for people who would not accept abolishing IP and copyright laws on philosophical grounds. Otherwise, for me its illegitimacy does not require evidence.
Re:Nokia Tells Reddit It Infringes Some Patents in Lead-Up t...
by wahnfrieden on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @11:46AM
(#39756966)
Same goes for means of production property
Re:Nokia Tells Reddit It Infringes Some Patents in Lead-Up t...
by Gormo on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @12:08PM
(#39757196)
The core criterion for whether something can be property is whether it is economically rival, i.e. whether possession/use by one party inherently excludes others from equivalent possession/use. This is true for all physical resources, including most items that people regard as "means of production", making them natural property, but isn't true for most of the things IP laws apply to.
Re:Nokia Tells Reddit It Infringes Some Patents in Lead-Up t...
by aaa_aaa on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @11:55AM
(#39757093)
No. That is property and can be owned. IP is not tangible, can be exactly copied once observed, without effecting the original.
There are some avid supporters of this strain of thought. Here is an example: albeit old, this may give some background:
https://mises.org/library/book/against-intellectual-property