News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In Economics Do We Know What We're Doing? Nobel Prize win... by jimmySixDOF on Monday March 18, 2024 @07:45AM (#39742761)
Quoting from the link [1]:

Milton Friedman's Thermostat

If a house has a good thermostat, we should observe a strong negative correlation between the amount of oil burned in the furnace (M), and the outside temperature (V). But we should observe no correlation between the amount of oil burned in the furnace (M) and the inside temperature (P). And we should observe no correlation between the outside temperature (V) and the inside temperature (P).

An econometrician, observing the data, concludes that the amount of oil burned had no effect on the inside temperature. Neither did the outside temperature. The only effect of burning oil seemed to be that it reduced the outside temperature. An increase in M will cause a decline in V, and have no effect on P.

A second econometrician, observing the same data, concludes that causality runs in the opposite direction. The only effect of an increase in outside temperature is to reduce the amount of oil burned. An increase in V will cause a decline in M, and have no effect on P.

But both agree that M and V are irrelevant for P. They switch off the furnace, and stop wasting their money on oil.

[1]https://worthwhile.typepad.com/worthwhile_canadian_initi/201...

Re:In Economics Do We Know What We're Doing? Nobel Prize win... by WhitneyLand on Monday March 18, 2024 @08:58AM (#39743763)
Re:In Economics Do We Know What We're Doing? Nobel Prize win... by GardenLetter27 on Monday March 18, 2024 @09:04AM (#39743853)
Econometrics without interventions is useless due to stuff like this.

At least with instrumental variables for example you could tax the oil and see the real impact of less oil burned.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Instrumental_variables_estimat...

Re:In Economics Do We Know What We're Doing? Nobel Prize win... by pcwelder on Monday March 18, 2024 @09:05AM (#39743880)
But this is textbook multi-collinearity that any student of economics should be able to observe and account for?

The article discusses much grander issues than these easy to identify problems with causal analysis.

Re:In Economics Do We Know What We're Doing? Nobel Prize win... by amatic on Monday March 18, 2024 @09:10AM (#39743930)
That's interesting, I've never heard of Milton Friedman's thermostat, but there is a procedure called "The test for the controlled variable" intended to find if a system is controlling one variable or another, invented by W.T. Powers sometime in the fifties, I think. You make a hypothesis about what is the controlled variable, then you apply a disturbance. If the variable stays relatively undisturbed, the correlation between the disturbance and the controlled variable will be nearly zero.
Re:In Economics Do We Know What We're Doing? Nobel Prize win... by JumpCrisscross on Monday March 18, 2024 @10:56AM (#39745439)
> But both agree that M and V are irrelevant for P. They switch off the furnace, and stop wasting their money on oil

If they have the power to switch off the furnace, an econometric construction is underpowered. The problem in economics is you often cannot switch off the furnace. You're forced to just watch it wondering.

Re:In Economics Do We Know What We're Doing? Nobel Prize win... by MichaelZuo on Monday March 18, 2024 @11:14AM (#39745679)
Technically ‘they’ do ‘have the power to switch off’, even switch off the whole of human civilization.

‘They’ just don’t have the power to switch back it on.

If you restrict ‘they’ to decision makers over WMDs.

Re:In Economics Do We Know What We're Doing? Nobel Prize win... by JumpCrisscross on Monday March 18, 2024 @11:27AM (#39745849)
> Technically ‘they’ do ‘have the power to switch off’, even switch off the whole of human civilization

No, economics researchers do not.

Re:In Economics Do We Know What We're Doing? Nobel Prize win... by MichaelZuo on Monday March 18, 2024 @04:07PM (#39749324)
Moonlighting as economics researchers, or even considering themselves as the superiors of economic researchers is possible, and can’t be excluded as a possibility. Hence why I said technically.
Re:In Economics Do We Know What We're Doing? Nobel Prize win... by fuzzfactor on Monday March 18, 2024 @01:44PM (#39747491)
>In Economics Do We Know What We're Doing?

Economics is pure research.

If you look away for a minute, or even blink, you might miss something important.

You can't be much of an economist without being immersed in research, so much more than anyone else would think reasonable.

Quoting one of the more mathematically gifted Nobel Prize winners;

“If we knew what it was we were doing, it would not be called research, would it?”

- A.Einstein