In fact, he said on twitter: " I don’t have any problem with you sharing my post. By all means! But the last two paragraphs were barely rewritten." (https://twitter.com/#!/endtwist/status/202089166975148033)
Sadly now, we should expect the classic "Oh crap, this story hit the top of HN, so here's a half-assed reactionary apology to try to save face" tactic that we've all seen before, which is incredibly lame.
Had he not been, for lack of a better term, such a defensive prick initially, and more upfront (or at least professional, you're the CEO for crying out loud) that would have been much better.
I learned this in my freshman year in college, this is so basic that an "editor" cannot claim ignorance of these rules.
Plagiarism In 1918 http://mikecanex.wordpress.com/2012/05/06/plagiarism-in-1918...
Looks awfully similar to Plagiarism in 2012.
Wonder if an average theft or rapist should be walking around with recent statistics of population being behind bars and why it should be ok to steal or rape.
http://web.mit.edu/academicintegrity/citing/whatandwhy.html
(To be honest, I got this link from wikipedia :)
You would still have to cite your sources, even if you copy the data. And any annotations are not part of the dataset. These annotations would ble equivalent to the article text, which was copied pretty much word for word.
Here in Norway they would expel you from all higher education for a minimum of 12 months for such plagiarism.
This policy is good for customers (so they can avoid your products) good for investors (so they can avoid investing in your company) and good for prospective employees (so they can not).
[1] Not that brutal honesty is always a cop-out, mind you.
http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2010/11/web-decries-infring...
It obviously has some keen similarities to your situation (particularly in the "editor's response" department).
While I'm a fan of fair use (it's what makes the world wide web go round), I'm also a fan of attribution...and more importantly, of handling PR like someone who's the public face of a company. I think the responses here on HN show that most of us think similarly.
All I get from this comment is that you basically don't give a shit, which also means you really should not be an editor as that role is entirely about accepting responsibility for what gets published.
Have you been taking notes from the tabloids by any chance?
If you have you had better have the bank balance to back the attitude because that is the only way they get away with this kind of shit while still remaining in business.
However, when you copy/use facts, you wade into hot water if you also copy the structure and the way those facts were originally expressed. The original TNW article shown here seems to step over that line with a barely masked copy of the original paragraphs.
What bothers me more, though, is that seemingly a CEO of a media organization has failed to do any damage control based around a genuine grievance (that wasn't even aggressively delivered). Saying things like "think it's pretty ridiculous that you're even getting the slightest bit annoyed about this", "needless to say, we'll be staying well clear of anything ur involved with in future for fear of ridiculous reaction" and using "u do realise that about 50% of all publications is content sourced from other publications right?" as a sort of defence is a horrible PR line for a proprietor to play, even if that's his honest opinion.