News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kickstarter 'Bug' Exposed Projects by fragsworth on Monday May 14, 2012 @03:10PM (#3972648)
I really doubt modifying a GET URL would be considered criminal in any court. It's far too easily accessible to everyone. It's two physical actions, a click and a keypress.
Re:Kickstarter 'Bug' Exposed Projects by tptacek on Monday May 14, 2012 @03:12PM (#3972657)
I'm pretty sure you're wrong. Ease has absolutely nothing to do with the statute. If a reasonable person could be expected to know that the pages they were accessing were unauthorized (or more precisely if a prosecutor or plaintiff's counsel could make a convincing argument), that's the ball game.

This is a very common misconception among tech people about how the CFAA works.

Re:Kickstarter 'Bug' Exposed Projects by mparlane on Monday May 14, 2012 @05:08PM (#3973290)
To be honest, if I changed an ID on a URL, I expect it to say "not found" or "not authorised" if I am not allowed to see it. If it doesn't say such things, than I can expect that it is ok to view.

That is what I have come to expect of such web pages.

Re:Kickstarter 'Bug' Exposed Projects by tptacek on Monday May 14, 2012 @05:10PM (#3973300)
Good luck.
Re:Kickstarter 'Bug' Exposed Projects by mparlane on Monday May 14, 2012 @05:44PM (#3973508)
So if I made a website called http://thisisstep1.com/

And it said "Coming soon."

And someone found out they can goto http://thisisstep2.com/.

Should I be able to say "But.. you aren't meant to go there!" ? At what point does your legal boundary lie for what is considered a public webpage and what is considered "not authorised."

Re:Kickstarter 'Bug' Exposed Projects by statictype on Monday May 14, 2012 @10:41PM (#3974590)
What matters is intent. Did you intend to go there with the purpose of violating some agreement? Or did you stumble there by accident. I think that makes a difference.
Re:Kickstarter 'Bug' Exposed Projects by chc on Monday May 14, 2012 @03:31PM (#3972729)
I think they could make a reasonable argument that they didn't know they would just be given the documents upon request if they weren't authorized. If I ask you for a hundred dollars and you give it to me with no force or trickery, that is not theft, because your giving it to me implies consent.

That's where I see ease of access coming into it: If you really don't take any effort to keep me out of something (even as little as telling me "stay out"), how do I distinguish that unauthorized content from content I'm authorized to access — and not only that, but make the distinction before I access it?

Re:Kickstarter 'Bug' Exposed Projects by tptacek on Monday May 14, 2012 @03:53PM (#3972865)
Do I think you'd be convicted for manipulating URLs idly to prove a point? No.

Do I think you'd be convicted for manipulating URLs and grabbing their entire database? Very possibly.

Do I think you could incur five figures of legal headache in either scenario? Yes, I think you could, depending on how savvy the "victim" is and how close to "fight or flight" you push them.

Re:Kickstarter 'Bug' Exposed Projects by danso on Monday May 14, 2012 @04:24PM (#3973057)
Yes, but that's with many, many laws, right? It depends on the prosecutor, defense, and jury.

The way it's been described so far, the reporter thought he had found an undocumented API...which, totally speaking out of guesswork here, could be as simple as seeing the json file being passed through the web inspector, seeing that there's an id field, and then iterating across it. The person has no expectation that when the id is of a private object, that the service would actually return that data.

Re:Kickstarter 'Bug' Exposed Projects by tptacek on Monday May 14, 2012 @04:31PM (#3973102)
As with most (but not all) criminal statutes, the intent matters. If you can clearly demonstrate that you had no intention of actually accessing information you weren't authorized to see, and, better yet, that you didn't set out with an express purpose of abusing someone else's application in order to gin up the material for a for-profit news story, you'll almost certainly end up OK... if by "end up OK" you mean "excruciating legal drama that concludes in your favor".

Let me be clear: I don't think Kickstarter is going to go after the WSJ, or even that most companies would raise a huge stink about this.