News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I'm answering questions from the 'hardest exam in the world' by eru on Monday May 14, 2012 @02:43PM (#3972494)
Determinism does hold up at the quantum level. Quantum mechanics is completely deterministic. Collapsing the wave function to a classic state, is the probabilistic aspect, if any.
Re:I'm answering questions from the 'hardest exam in the world' by pron on Monday May 14, 2012 @03:05PM (#3972627)
I think that quantom mechanics makes us think differently about probability and determinism by giving the mathematical (human created) concept of probability a physical meaning. Similar to the example in intuition 2, a coin toss could be considered determinstic even if we do not try to predict the result. It is pre-determined that given a large enough number of coin tosses, very close to 50% of them would come out heads. Qunatom mechanics makes us consider probability as a physical property inherent in all physical objects. This way of thinking helps reasoning about genetic predisposition as well (which is always probabilistic). Just like any coin is "free" to make a choice, and yet it is certain that they would (almost) precisely split down the middle, so too can genetic predisposition can be said to be both constraining and not constraining at all at the same time.
Re:I'm answering questions from the 'hardest exam in the world' by mcarvin on Monday May 14, 2012 @03:19PM (#3972683)
Admittedly beyond at the limits of what this armchair quantum mechanic can say with confidence but to borrow from Hawkings... probabilities in quantum mechanics "reflect a fundamental randomness in nature" [The Grand Design]. So while quantum theories are testable, they are not always predictive (necessary for determinism).