News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Harvard concluded that a dishonesty expert committed misc... by beezlebroxxxxxx on Friday March 15, 2024 @06:35AM (#39714046)
Alternative, and more likely imo, hypothesis is that attaining and maintaining the social (and probably $$$) capital of being a "Harvard Expert" leads to desperation and breaking the rules.
Re:Harvard concluded that a dishonesty expert committed misc... by gwd on Friday March 15, 2024 @07:04AM (#39714212)
Sure, that might have been the "trigger"; but that's missing the key thing that needs to be explained. If this were dishonesty by someone doing chemistry, it's unlikely that this would have hit the front page of HN. As they say, "Dog bites man isn't a story; man bites dog is."

But a priori, you'd expect someone studying honesty* to personally care about honesty, and thus to be less likely to give in to these sorts of pressures. That's the thing that needs to be explained; the "man bites dog" aspect.

* EDIT s/honestly/honesty/g;

Re:Harvard concluded that a dishonesty expert committed misc... by JackeJR on Friday March 15, 2024 @08:20AM (#39714719)
The researcher was studying dishonesty... So I gather that she was more interested in dishonesty?
Re:Harvard concluded that a dishonesty expert committed misc... by Kamq on Friday March 15, 2024 @07:45AM (#39714440)
> But a priori, you'd expect someone studying honestly to personally care about honestly, and thus to be less likely to give in to these sorts of pressures.

I'm not so sure you can automatically assume this. You can definitely assume that the subject interests them.

But it's also possible that someone studying honesty/dishonesty might start seeing the subject in academic/technical terms instead of moral terms. Which may give them much less of a disincentive to be dishonest than the average person.

Which is to say that repeated studying and analysis of instances where people are dishonest may break down the gut reaction people have to being dishonest.

Re:Harvard concluded that a dishonesty expert committed misc... by gwd on Friday March 15, 2024 @07:53AM (#39714512)
I didn't say one should assume it, just that many people do. "Chemistry researcher committed fraud" is simply not the same as "Dishonesty expert committed fraud".

You give an alternate explanation, but it's still an explanation; one which wouldn't be needed (and indeed wouldn't apply) to a chemistry researcher.

A variation on your explanation might be: Dishonesty researchers discover just how easy it is for dishonest people to cheat the system, and how little consequence there is, and so is more tempted to be dishonest.

Re:Harvard concluded that a dishonesty expert committed misc... by verisimi on Friday March 15, 2024 @07:46AM (#39714454)
> But a priori, you'd expect someone studying honestly to personally care about honestly

But then, why study honesty if you already know what it is?

For me, this sort of thing - an honesty expert - is in the same realm as 'ethics panels'.

These folk are there to abuse edge case arguments (think "trolley problem") in order to provide moral cover for corporations to act dishonestly, unethically. And they will provide documentation in support. CEOs will just do what they wanted, but call it "moral" tm.

Re:Harvard concluded that a dishonesty expert committed misc... by yellowstuff on Friday March 15, 2024 @08:30AM (#39714777)
Probably the most important reason this story got big is because it involved Dan Ariely, a popular author and perhaps the most famous active researcher in the world.
Re:Harvard concluded that a dishonesty expert committed misc... by hn_throwaway_99 on Friday March 15, 2024 @09:03AM (#39715028)
Strong disagree. Literally every story I've read about this starts by talking about Francesca Gino.
Re:Harvard concluded that a dishonesty expert committed misc... by zaphirplane on Friday March 15, 2024 @08:31AM (#39714791)
lawyer broke law or accountant tax cheat or doctor kidney thief or lock smith cat burglar

People using their skills dishonestly is the theme of the story

Re:Harvard concluded that a dishonesty expert committed misc... by globalnode on Friday March 15, 2024 @09:11AM (#39715083)
computer professional caught hacking!
Re:Harvard concluded that a dishonesty expert committed misc... by almostnormal on Friday March 15, 2024 @09:13AM (#39715101)
> As they say, "Dog bites man isn't a story; man bites dog is."

The headline is just making fun of theory and practice. If some is a murder expert, is that some one who understands murder or someone highly qualified to kill people?

Therefore, the title is about a "dishonesty expert" matching the practice, not about a "honesty expert", which could be replaced by any other field.

Re:Harvard concluded that a dishonesty expert committed misc... by pixl97 on Friday March 15, 2024 @10:35AM (#39716233)
> not about a "honesty expert", which could be replaced by any other field.

Surely not marketing and sales!

Re:Harvard concluded that a dishonesty expert committed misc... by philwelch on Friday March 15, 2024 @09:54AM (#39715498)
Reminds me of the grad student in criminology who allegedly committed a brutal multiple murder in Moscow, Idaho. He got caught, so I guess he wasn’t as smart as he thought he was.