News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Devin, the First AI Software Engineer by HarHarVeryFunny on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @03:28PM (#39683827)
Let's get realistic here - I just beat GPT-4 at tic tac toe, since it failed to block my 2/3 complete winning line ...

Sure, one day we'll have AGI, and one day AGI will replace many jobs that can be done in front of a computer.

In the meantime, SOTA AI appears to be an airline chatbot that gets the company sued for lying to the customer. This is just basic question answering, and it can't even get that right. Would you trust it to write the autopilot code to fly the airplane? Maybe to write a tiny bit of it - just code up one function, perhaps?

I sure as hell wouldn't, and when it can be trusted to write one function that meets requirements and has no bugs, it's still going to be a LONG way before it can replace the job of the developers who were given a task of "write us an autopilot".

Re:Devin, the First AI Software Engineer by sohzm on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @01:01AM (#39688264)
Well, I'll bring the perspective of a recent college graduate from India.

Most students who started jobs in software aren't writing software for aeroplanes. They're writing crud apps, doing third-party API integrations or doing basic debugging.

I worry that although not some specialized software devs but a lot will still have problems due to stuff like this.

I'm not talking today, but say 2-3 years down the line, who will have an intern when you can get an AI intern that can perform as the top percentile and comes at $20 per month subscription?

Re:Devin, the First AI Software Engineer by HarHarVeryFunny on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @09:10AM (#39690911)
Certainly some software jobs are easier than others, and anything that is more just coding (e.g. crud apps) than designing would be easier to automate. It's interesting though why this hasn't been done a long time ago? I remember a piece of software called "The Last One" from the 1980's that was meant to automate creation of simple business apps like these, and here we are 40 years later with people still creating "no/low code" solutions, and people still manually writing crud apps! Why?

I don't think AI will replace jobs until it can do the entire job (full lifecycle from requirements to bug fixes, etc) and be interacted with in the same way a boss or team lead could interact with a developer. If you still need a person in the loop then it's not a person replacement - it's a productivity tool.

Re:Devin, the First AI Software Engineer by ozim on Wednesday March 13, 2024 @06:41PM (#39698467)
Imagine in 2-3 years time how much more crud software will be built and will be there to support. I'd say at least an order of magnitude more.

Even if I would have an AI assistant if I work on something I still have to understand that piece of work, I have to understand the requirements to give correct orders to the AI. I might become more efficient but I don't see an order of magnitude speed up where now I work on 5-8 projects which are in one ecosystem and I don't see suddenly switching to working on 50-80 projects where each 10 of them are different ecosystem that I also have to understand to make valid decisions - even if these are crud apps.