News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Do we know enough about the safety of quat disinfectants? by londons_explore on Sunday March 10, 2024 @01:45PM (#39660982)
I really want to see stuff like this tested in massive cohorts (ie. 1 billion+ participants) via variable dosing.

Here's how it would work:

* Companies that make products would randomly increase by 5% or decrease by 5% the dosage of each ingredient in a product headed to a specific town.

* The government would publish A/B groupings for every town in the US and every chemical they track.

* Average health data would be collected, and whenever a specific chemicals A/B group difference exceeds some threshold, investigation is done.

The main downside is production costs of products goes up, since every product will now have a final step of adding all the A/B adjustment doses to the bottle before sealing. But I believe this is worth it for rooting out chemicals that have low level yet very widespread negative effects.

Re:Do we know enough about the safety of quat disinfectants? by twisteriffic on Sunday March 10, 2024 @01:51PM (#39661035)
Maybe we should just spray each town from the air and cut out the middleman? While we're at it we can infect a portion with polio just to see what happens.
Re:Do we know enough about the safety of quat disinfectants? by MiddleMan5 on Sunday March 10, 2024 @02:16PM (#39661229)
Sarcasm aside, I agree testing on populations raises a whole bunch of ethical and morality concerns.

Also how would we control for environmental health effects, or even interactions between multiple product variances. This kind of testing would be wildly expensive, pose potential public health risks, and the data collected would be coarse and noisy at best

Re:Do we know enough about the safety of quat disinfectants? by londons_explore on Sunday March 10, 2024 @03:17PM (#39661747)
This would only be of substances already approved for general use, and wouldn't expose anyone to any substance they wouldn't otherwise be buying/using.

The only difference is it very slightly adjusts the quantity - and does so in a way that is within existing allowed tolerances, so effectively this might already be happening, just we aren't collecting the results.

Re:Do we know enough about the safety of quat disinfectants? by twisteriffic on Sunday March 10, 2024 @03:20PM (#39661771)
Wait.... You weren't being sarcastic? This suddenly isn't funny any more.
Re:Do we know enough about the safety of quat disinfectants? by mrob on Sunday March 10, 2024 @02:32PM (#39661367)
Products are already allowed to contain slightly more or less than is stated on the packaging so long as the average is high enough:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estimated_sign

By tightening the required tolerances, londons_explore's proposal could be implemented without exposing anybody to different levels of product than are already permitted.

Re:Do we know enough about the safety of quat disinfectants? by pbhjpbhj on Sunday March 10, 2024 @03:28PM (#39661834)
I was thinking 5% was probably within the range of ordinary variations for a lot of domestically used chemicals .. that might mean one could already do such a study.

However, you have to get people to tell you how much product they use, which brands, how often, and not lie about it. That's basically impossible without antisocial levels of monitoring (which supermarkets probably already do, but which they don't want to tell their customers they do).

It's like the early days of mass customer data tracking where they'd tell customers they were probably pregnant, or probably gay, or whatever. People didn't receive the information in a way that suggested they were happy about the data being gathered.

It's probably too unethical to even use that data. Unless you're only trying to sell more crap, then it's A-OK! /s