News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I'm Betting on Call-by-Push-Value by 082349872349872 on Sunday March 10, 2024 @07:47AM (#39658407)
If it doesn't evaluate functions, how do closures get their lexical environments?
Re:I'm Betting on Call-by-Push-Value by mrkeen on Monday March 11, 2024 @06:47AM (#39666489)
How do they figure out what goes into their environment, or how do their environments get populated?

I believe the first happens at compile time, and the second happens after the function is passed.

  1  f x =
  2    let xx = x * x in
  3    (\y -> y + xx)
  4
  5  main = do
  6    let clo = f 2
  7    let applied = clo 3
  8    print applied
The closure is defined on line 3, and instantiated on line 6.

xx is known to be the captured variable at compile time. But in a lazy setting, it's fine for the closure to be passed around before the value of xx is known:

  f x =
    let xx = trace "Evaluating xx" (x * x) in
    trace "Returning closure" (\y -> y + xx)

  main = do
    let clo = f 2
    let applied = clo 3
    print applied
> Returning closure

> Evaluating xx

> 7