News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Mystery Social Media Account Schooling Congress on Ho... by romwell on Friday March 08, 2024 @03:29PM (#39645999)
>People are acting like this guy is some sort of savant.

And we have an extensive record that shows that he is one.

>Congressional procedure is not even remotely as complex as what you need to know to build an average office building

[Citation needed].

Unless you're both a congressman and a construction worker, this is just an unqualified (i.e., worthless) opinion.

In contrast, the opinion that this guy is some sort of savant is that of professional staff on the Hill (named in the article), and is, by definition, qualified.

>But we're talking about knowledge that a 20 year old UK college student picked up in his spare time by watching TV and reading a few books

You just described every historian which learns from primary sources.

And "watching TV" is a very peculiar way to describe "watching live broadcasts of Congressional hearings and pouring through the archives".

>Specifically it reveals how few national politicians, consultants, staffers, reporters, etc. in DC want to do boring-seeming work like reading a procedural manual and some history.

"I refuse to acknowledge that a 20 year old can be exceptional, so I baselessly assert that literally everyone in the field must be stupid and inept instead"

>The commentary on this Twitter account (including this article) says way more about the people commenting on it.

Indeed it does. And to a larger extent than you seem to be aware of.

Re:The Mystery Social Media Account Schooling Congress on Ho... by pdonis on Friday March 08, 2024 @04:02PM (#39646450)
> the opinion that this guy is some sort of savant is that of professional staff on the Hill (named in the article), and is, by definition, qualified.

"Qualified" based on their personal experience with what is apparently common practice for Congress and its staffers, yes. But that just means that the common practice for Congress and its staffers involves an appalling level of ignorance about the rules and procedures of the very institution they are working for.

To run with the construction analogy, it's as if a bunch of structural engineers were calling a college student on Twitter who isn't even majoring in engineering a "savant" for having and sharing detailed knowledge of how to do load calculations to determine what size I-beams are required for a bridge or a building, based on reading the reference works that describe the details of those calculations. Yes, it would be impressive that a college student not majoring in engineering could gain such a detailed knowledge of structural engineering calculations in their spare time. But it would emphatically not be impressive for the people who are supposed to already have all that knowledge to be calling the college student a "savant".

Re:The Mystery Social Media Account Schooling Congress on Ho... by romwell on Friday March 08, 2024 @08:48PM (#39648703)
>But that just means that the common practice for Congress and its staffers involves an appalling level of ignorance about the rules and procedures of the very institution they are working for.&

And what basis do you have to say that their "level of ignorance" is, indeed, "appalling"?

Let me guess, it's the fact that they found the expertise of the 20-year-old useful, isn't it?

Circular logic at its finest.

>To run with the construction analogy,...*

Oh, an unqualified (i.e. worthless) construction analogy, based on zero experience in subject matter. Great.

An analogy can be used to clarify your point (which is unnecessary - it's clear enough), but in itself, it can't be used to argue your point is valid, because you have zero basis to say that this analogy applies.

Maybe he's sharing the equivalent of I-beam sizes. Maybe he's sharing the equivalent of a Space X rocket blueprint.

You don't know which analogy is applicable, because you are not an expert in the field and your opinion is unqualified. And nobody should be convinced by your argument, since it is supported only by the conclusion you're trying to arrive at.

Re:The Mystery Social Media Account Schooling Congress on Ho... by pdonis on Friday March 08, 2024 @09:08PM (#39648809)
> what basis do you have to say that their "level of ignorance" is, indeed, "appalling"?

Um, the fact that they did not know the rules of their own institution?

If you don't find that appalling, I gotta ask, why not? These are the people who run Congress. It's their job to know these things.

> Circular logic at its finest.

Not at all. Just applying common sense to what people who run an institution ought to know as part of their jobs. See above.

> based on zero experience in subject matter.

Um, actually, no, I have considerable experience in the construction industry. That's why I picked that particular analogy to run with: beacuse I do know what people whose job it is to do things like structural engineering calculations are expected to know, and I can compare that with what my common sense would expect people whose job it is to run Congress would be expected to know.

> nobody should be convinced by your argument

It seems to me that if anyone here is making arguments based on unwarranted assumptions and zero actual information, it's you.

Re:The Mystery Social Media Account Schooling Congress on Ho... by romwell on Friday March 08, 2024 @11:55PM (#39649479)
>Um, the fact that they did not know the rules of their own institution? If you don't find that appalling, I gotta ask, why not? These are the people who run Congress. It's their job to know these things.

I'd say that problem is that the rules are too obscure, unclear, complicated, and unsuited for the way they are used today.

It is appalling that we are at that stage, but assuming that the rules are simple, and the staffers are inept is unwarranted.

>Not at all. Just applying common sense to what people who run an institution ought to know as part of their jobs. See above.

Ah, same common sense that would require any lawyer to just know all the laws and precedent.

Similarly, every software engineer just knows the full spec of all programming languages, and in particular = C++, and would not ever need to resort to StackOverflow to look up or ask a question. It's just common sense!

Wait, no, it isn't, and your entire argument boils down to "it's just common sense that I'm right!".

For one, the US Congress is not a common institution, but even if it were, it's just common sense!" isn't even an argument.

>Um, actually, no, I have considerable experience in the construction industry.

The subject matter is congressional rules. You can talk about construction all day long, but your opinions on the subject matter are unqualified and based on zero experience (i.e. worthless).

Again, you aren't even trying to present any basis for why the work of that 20-year-old isn't deep and complex.

>It seems to me that if anyone here is making arguments based on unwarranted assumptions and zero actual information, it's you.

It seems incorrectly. I am basing my opinions on the information presented in the article, and on the qualified opinions of the professionals in the field who, having many years of experience, do think that person is a savant.

Also, a person quoted in the article commented in this very thread, saying essentially the same things as I said above [1].

So, I have a lot of basis for my assumptions, as well as actual information.

You're welcome to peruse it.

[1]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39648859

Re:The Mystery Social Media Account Schooling Congress on Ho... by pdonis on Saturday March 09, 2024 @12:16AM (#39649567)
> I'd say that problem is that the rules are too obscure, unclear, complicated, and unsuited for the way they are used today.

Then it's the job of the people who run Congress to fix that. Which requires them to know what the rules currently are, so they can figure out how to fix them.

> assuming that the rules are simple

I made no such assumption.

> and the staffers are inept is unwarranted.

I didn't assume the staffers are inept; I concluded it from their observed behavior. I don't see what else I could conclude from the fact that they don't know the rules that it's their job to know.

> same common sense that would require any lawyer to just know all the laws and precedent.

Not off the top of their head, but being able to look them up without having to depend on someone on Twitter, yes. Similarly, the people who run Congress should be able to find this information themselves; they shouldn't have to depend on someone on Twitter to do it.

> every software engineer just knows the full spec of all programming languages

Not all of them, because no software engineer uses all of them. But for the ones you do use, yes, you should have a good working knowledge of their spec, and should be able to look up details when you need to, and not depend on someone on Twitter (or Stack Overflow, for that matter) to do it.

If you're at the stage where you're having to ask people on the Internet about such things, you aren't yet a software engineer. You're just an aspiring one. The people who run Congress are not "aspiring" to that job. They have it. Big difference.

Apparently you have much lower standards than I do for what people are supposed to know as part of their jobs.

> you aren't even trying to present any basis for why the work of that 20-year-old isn't deep and complex.

I have made no such claim. I am claiming that the work of that 20-year-old should be being done by Congress and its staffers. That's their job. The fact that the work required is "deep and complex" does not excuse Congress and its staffers from doing it.

> the qualified opinions of the professionals in the field who, having many years of experience, do think that person is a savant.

Again, you're missing my point. I'm not saying that the 20-year-old is not a "savant". I'm saying that the fact that Congress and its staffers are calling him one means that they are not doing their jobs. If they were doing their jobs, their response to him would be something like "Wow, you have a level of knowledge of this stuff pretty close to ours." Not "wow, can we ask you questions because we can't be bothered to do our jobs ourselves?"

Re:The Mystery Social Media Account Schooling Congress on Ho... by romwell on Saturday March 09, 2024 @12:52AM (#39649711)
>But for the ones you do use, yes, you should have a good working knowledge of their spec, and should be able to look up details when you need to, and not depend on someone on Twitter (or Stack Overflow, for that matter) to do it.

The staffers don't depend on Twitter to do their job, and software engineers don't need to depend on Stack Overflow to use it.

To say that people who ask questions on Stack Overflow aren't yet software engineers is asinine.

>If you're at the stage where you're having to ask people on the Internet about such things, you aren't yet a software engineer. You're just an aspiring one.

If your definition of proficiency is "never asks questions", then your definition is a bad one.

Otherwise, it makes no difference whether questions are asked on the Internet or not.

>If they were doing their jobs, their response to him would be something like "Wow, you have a level of knowledge of this stuff pretty close to ours." Not "Hey, can we ask you questions because we can't be bothered to do our jobs ourselves?"

They are doing their jobs. The responsibility for the job falls on them. And if they can use a resource (an enthusiastic savant, Twitter, reddit, ChatGPT, ...) that allows them to do it faster, they're doing a good job.

As a software engineer, if you are spending an hour on something you could find out by asking in 5 minutes (taking 5 minutes of your time, and 5 minutes of someone else's), you are a bad software engineer, and are wasting your employer's money.

Re:The Mystery Social Media Account Schooling Congress on Ho... by pdonis on Saturday March 09, 2024 @12:53PM (#39653425)
> The staffers don't depend on Twitter to do their job

Sure looks to me like they are. I guess we'll just have to disagree.

Re:The Mystery Social Media Account Schooling Congress on Ho... by romwell on Sunday March 10, 2024 @06:44AM (#39658165)
Fair. Seems like that's the root of disagreement.

If they can't do their job without Twitter, then I can agree with the rest of what you said.

Sadly, the entire Congress is so dysfunctional that it's very hard to determine whether the staffers do or don't do a good job (and which of these possibilities is a better one).

That's the part which the UK student doesn't seem to get (and which makes me feel the savant label is fitting): knowing all the rules doesn't matter when playing by the rules isn't a goal.

Same goes for having the power which they never intended to use in the first place, because the unwritten rules matter more.

The whole thing about rules is that without a central enforcement mechanism, it's all about whether you have enough clout and chutzpah to use or break a certain rule. Just because a rule exists (and has been enacted before), doesn't mean invoking it isn't free.

It's just cheaper than doing the same thing against the rules.

Re:The Mystery Social Media Account Schooling Congress on Ho... by Mathnerd314 on Friday March 08, 2024 @04:08PM (#39646520)
> > Congressional procedure is not even remotely as complex as what you need to know to build an average office building

> [Citation needed].

We can just compare the books, per the article the Congressional procedures are 1000 pages and the International Building code is 832 pages https://shop.iccsafe.org/2021-international-building-coder.h.... So at first glance building seems easier. But then when you crack it open, you also need to read up on gas, mechanical, plumbing, fire, and energy efficiency, so there is an extra 200+186+270+692+302=1650 pages. So I think it is true - a Congressperson only needs one book, but to build an office building you need 6 books (and probably 6 people, each specialized in a book). Now building a residential house, that is the IRC which is roughly comparable in page count to Congress, and you do see house flipping businesses run by a single well-versed entrepreneur.

Re:The Mystery Social Media Account Schooling Congress on Ho... by romwell on Friday March 08, 2024 @08:40PM (#39648642)
>We can just compare the books, per the article the Congressional procedures are 1000 pages and the International Building code is 832 pages

It keeps getting better!

Coming next: judging the complexity, importance, and impact of code by line count alone.

Re:The Mystery Social Media Account Schooling Congress on Ho... by IIAOPSW on Friday March 08, 2024 @06:02PM (#39647579)
>"I refuse to acknowledge that a 20 year old can be exceptional, so I baselessly assert that literally everyone in the field must be stupid and inept instead"

Why not both. An above average (but not savant) 20 year old who appears more exceptional than he is because the professional class he's being compared with really does have a lot of rot.

Re:The Mystery Social Media Account Schooling Congress on Ho... by romwell on Friday March 08, 2024 @08:38PM (#39648637)
>Why not both.

Because there's no basis or evidence for the latter claim (hence, baseless).

The justification "look how inept they are, they rely on a help of a 20-year old" is just circular reasoning, and nothing else has been presented.

Re:The Mystery Social Media Account Schooling Congress on Ho... by defen on Friday March 08, 2024 @10:31PM (#39649186)
I think it's worthwhile to ask - in what other fields do exceptional people become consensus world-class experts after four years of part-time study?
Re:The Mystery Social Media Account Schooling Congress on Ho... by romwell on Saturday March 09, 2024 @12:24AM (#39649596)
It's rare in any field, that's why he's coonsidered a savant.

But it's possible in many fields too - including mathematics[1][2][3], aerospace engineering [4][5], theoretical physics[6], computer science[7], etc.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Srinivasa_Ramanujan

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stefan_Banach

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oliver_Heaviside

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wright_brothers

[5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Konstantin_Tsiolkovsky

[6] https://insidetheperimeter.ca/where-did-it-come-from-bose-la...

[7] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linus_Torvalds

Re:The Mystery Social Media Account Schooling Congress on Ho... by debo_ on Saturday March 09, 2024 @12:26AM (#39649606)
Javascript?