I'm not sure I grok this. Do you mean, for example, sending a token in the POST body, or as a cookie / other header?
One disadvantage to having a secret in the URL, versus in a header or body, is that it can appear in web service logs, unless you use a URI fragment. Even then, the URL is visible to the user, and will live in their history and URL bar - from which they may copy and paste it elsewhere.
Extremely different. The former depends on the existence of a contract about URL privacy (not to mention third parties actually adhering to it) when no such contract exists. Any design for an auth/auth mechanism that depends on private links is inherently broken. The very phrase "private link" is an oxymoron.
> I am not sure why you think that having an obscure URI format will somehow give you a secure call (whatever that means). Identifiers are public information.
<https://roy.gbiv.com/untangled/2008/rest-apis-must-be-hypert...>
And I think for me it comes down to the fact that the tokens can be issued on a per-customer basis, and access logs can be monitored to watch for suspicious behaviour and revoke accordingly.
Also, as others have mentioned, there's just a different mindset around how much it matters that the list of names of files be kept a secret. On the scale of things Amazon might randomly screw up, accidentally listing the filenames sitting in your public bucket sounds pretty low on the priority list since 99% of their users wouldn't care.