Re:NY Times issues DMCA takedowns of Wordle clones
by Etherlord87 on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @06:50PM
(#39623348)
Imagine that someone on the street said you have red shoes, but he had red shoes first. So you should remove shoes.
And you comply. But you're not sad about it - in your opinion it makes intellectual capital a value. E.g. you now believe it is worth to wear a particular color of a particular apparel first and so on.
The problem: it was never stated by some kind of an authority, that the bully was right. He might as well have been wrong, and you granted his wish to remove your shoes simply on the basis of, to put it lightly, not being assertive enough.
Re:NY Times issues DMCA takedowns of Wordle clones
by nybble41 on Friday March 08, 2024 @09:40PM
(#39648979)
Or to put it another way, the "intellectual capital" argument presupposes that you aspire to become a bully yourself, and live among a society of similar bullies. There is no incentivising effect on someone who wishes to innovate without abusing the legal system to stop others from creating similar things.
Treating it as a case study how to protect the rights. One might say that it is against freedom etc., but in my opinion this makes intellectual capital a value. E.g. I now believe it is worth to invest in innovations and so on. (It does not mean I will do it as I lack the will and resources.) When I was younger I didn't know how to protect my code and capitalise it, therefore this case resonates with me in such way.