News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'We had to educate Oracle about our contract,' CIO says a... by zaphar on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @12:49PM (#39618626)
Look, if you are already in business with Oracle then you have my condolences. But if you aren't in business with them then there is absolutely no world where you should ever under any circumstances consider getting into business with them.

Nothing their database does can't be done with a different database. Even paying for a proprietary database can be done with a different party than Oracle. Do not, I repeat, do not do business with Oracle under any circumstances.

If you are already an Oracle customer and you have the opportunity to drop them from your stack. Do not hesitate, Do not pause, Immediately take that opportunity. There is no downside only upside in not doing business with Oracle.

Re:'We had to educate Oracle about our contract,' CIO says a... by whiterknight on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @01:13PM (#39619000)
How is there such a big disconnect between HN opinion on Oracle and business use?

Is it maybe the least bad of all the bad options? Does it cover some edge cases which the obvious FOSS solutions don’t?

Re:'We had to educate Oracle about our contract,' CIO says a... by vetinari on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @01:35PM (#39619322)
Tech people are those, who have to fix everything once SHTF.

Business people are those, who get to go to nice trips and dinners for their "right" decision.

Any other questions?

Re:'We had to educate Oracle about our contract,' CIO says a... by peteradio on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @02:04PM (#39619834)
Greasy palms have no qualms!
Re:'We had to educate Oracle about our contract,' CIO says a... by zaphar on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @01:22PM (#39619127)
I honestly don't know. I don't know how they stay in business since every developer I've ever met had a bordering on irrational hatred of them.

The only people I've met who like them were all Oracle consultants of some sort and not what I would call developers. When I've been forced to use an Oracle database it was because the company had a contract with Oracle and didn't want to allow any other database to be used. The decision was always several levels above my paygrade. I no longer accept positions at the kind of place that will do business with Oracle. It tends to signal that leadership of that place has some serious problems and too much money to realize they have those problems.

Re:'We had to educate Oracle about our contract,' CIO says a... by SoftTalker on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @01:45PM (#39619497)
I never worked for Oracle or as an Oracle consultant, but used to develop on Oracle RDBMS. I liked it quite a lot and it was very powerful. But today, I'd use Postgres.
Re:'We had to educate Oracle about our contract,' CIO says a... by zaphar on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @01:51PM (#39619611)
In purely technical terms Oracle is fine, really good even. The company comes with massive legal and cost risks though.
Re:'We had to educate Oracle about our contract,' CIO says a... by rstuart4133 on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @04:38PM (#39621895)
> I don't know how they stay in business since every developer I've ever met had a bordering on irrational hatred of them.

I'm sure you know the answer. Oracle doesn't sell to developers. They sell to the management of non-tech companies whose upper echelons are staffed by people with expertise whatever they do, which might be selling dresses or making plastic pipes. For what it's with SAP uses exactly the same technique.

For something truly difficult to explain, try Google replacing Oracle with SAP. https://www.zdnet.com/article/google-migrates-from-oracle-fi...

Years ago when I invoiced Google they asked me to enter the invoice into their portal. (Generally, transcribing a vendors invoice into your accounting systems is something you pay your own employees to do of course, but big companies know how to apply the screws.) I remember that web form. It proudly said is was created by a summer of code student. It was ugly, it was concise, it was straightforward, and it just worked first go. Then Google moved to SAP, and used SAP's Aruba service to do the same thing. Aruba is layer upon layer of poor design, outages and bugs. Now, if a Google employee sends you an purchase they often offer to "get it into the system" for you. The reason is Aruba is almost unusable, so it they need whatever service is being offered badly enough they shepherd it through.

I can only guess, but my explanation is assume SAP sold the system to Google's accounting department. Somehow, SAP's sales found a way to bypass the ocean of expertise inside one of the greatest software engineering companies on the planet and sell the system to a pocket of people who had no idea about what they were buying. Colour me impressed with SAP sales.

Re:'We had to educate Oracle about our contract,' CIO says a... by gadflyinyoureye on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @01:26PM (#39619186)
Many large companies want a Batphone to call someone for support. They think that the vendor will magically just make things work. Normally that’s not the case. They might get it to work faster than your people, but probably not much quicker.

FOSS often has a Batphone, but few people pay for it. As a result management doesn’t want their Ops to be the only possible team to correct things.

Re:'We had to educate Oracle about our contract,' CIO says a... by JoshuaRogers on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @01:43PM (#39619459)
Absolutely. I’m surprised that the belief in much of the comments is that the technical input of developers (like myself) affects whether Oracle gets consideration.

Oracle gets consideration because teams want to have a lifeline if something goes wrong or (worst case) someone else to pin the blame on when it does. And this happens because some businesses are actually so big that that level of comfort doesn’t even dent the budget.

Oracle actually has some nice parts and some rough edges (a statement that applies equally to PG and SQL Server too, for instance), but it comes with a king-sized security blanket.

Re:'We had to educate Oracle about our contract,' CIO says a... by zaphar on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @01:49PM (#39619571)
What is weird is that there are many good technical reasons to use Oracle. It's a very advanced and impressive database. The risks from doing business with Oracle are nearly all legal and business cost related. The sort of thing that are squarely under the supposed expertise of the non developer folks.

My objections against Oracle are not technical in nature. It is almost entirely cost and legal risk related.

Re:'We had to educate Oracle about our contract,' CIO says a... by zaphar on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @01:37PM (#39619357)
You can get a Batphone without doing business with Oracle. Microsoft SQL Server will give you a Batphone and would still be better than doing business with Oracle.
Re:'We had to educate Oracle about our contract,' CIO says a... by seniorThrowaway on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @01:47PM (#39619545)
I don't know if it is still the case but MS SQL was very deficient tech wise against Oracle DB, and never really a contender for a large OLTP DB. To the point that for some applications, it simply would not work due to excessive locking.
Re:'We had to educate Oracle about our contract,' CIO says a... by zaphar on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @01:52PM (#39619628)
I've used MS SQL recently and it holds up more than fine if you tune it properly. Oracle also needs tuning properly so that's not big deal.
Re:'We had to educate Oracle about our contract,' CIO says a... by seniorThrowaway on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @01:43PM (#39619458)
support contracts are mitigations to management career problems, not to technology problems. Managers always want that throat to choke to deflect blame or buy time
Re:'We had to educate Oracle about our contract,' CIO says a... by codeslave13 on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @01:11PM (#39618944)
Just dont go SAP about as bad as oracle haveing worked in both shops.
Re:'We had to educate Oracle about our contract,' CIO says a... by zaphar on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @01:13PM (#39618982)
I have no experience with SAP. But I've heard that you could just substitute SAP for Oracle in the above and it would be just as true.
Re:'We had to educate Oracle about our contract,' CIO says a... by 7thaccount on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @03:02PM (#39620638)
My father worked on a multi year project to replace their darling (but very old mainframe system) with SAP. Apparently it's just awful and basically everything required a custom and tons of SAP consultants. By the time you're done, you had to reimplement the entire system on top of SAP with a ton of workarounds. That was his experience anyway.
Re:'We had to educate Oracle about our contract,' CIO says a... by inemesitaffia on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @03:12PM (#39620784)
>Nothing

Thier transactions and rollbacks and logging actually work

Re:'We had to educate Oracle about our contract,' CIO says a... by zaphar on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @03:18PM (#39620860)
They work just fine on Postgres and MS SQL too.
Re:'We had to educate Oracle about our contract,' CIO says a... by mianos on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @03:59PM (#39621371)
Not in MySQL. DDL is not transacted last time I looked Postgres is a great choice over Oracle these days though
Re:'We had to educate Oracle about our contract,' CIO says a... by zaphar on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @04:48PM (#39622055)
Yeah, well MySQL or Oracle aren't the only database choices you have. And those two aren't even a choice between Oracle and something else. Both are Oracle the company properties now. Unless you meant MariaDB or something.
Re:'We had to educate Oracle about our contract,' CIO says a... by mianos on Monday March 11, 2024 @01:49AM (#39665230)
Yes, my mistake, I miss-read MS SQL as MySQL. MS SQL, being derived from Sybase, fully supports transactions. I'm not a fan of the price, but it's good.