Re:Alan Kay's talk at UCLA – Feb 21, 2024 [video]
by ssivark on Thursday March 07, 2024 @03:48PM
(#39634420)
> In contrast, when communicating with an OS or engineering a mechanical device, ambiguity is a negative and it's crucial to use language that is deterministic.
Very much a historical artifact. Modern systems (LLMs, for example) can in principle handle ambiguous inputs.
Re:Alan Kay's talk at UCLA – Feb 21, 2024 [video]
by AlchemistCamp on Friday March 08, 2024 @03:25PM
(#39645952)
Is ambiguity ever desirable when communicating with them?
Re:Alan Kay's talk at UCLA – Feb 21, 2024 [video]
by carbotaniuman on Friday March 08, 2024 @06:56PM
(#39647994)
I would argue no - the entire concept of prompt engineering exists for this reason.
One example is ambiguity. Every human language has faculties for ambiguity, which is crucial in many human interactions and relationships. The ability to make implicit requests or suggestions while maintaining plausible deniability is valuable, even in situations that are non-adversarial.
In contrast, when communicating with an OS or engineering a mechanical device, ambiguity is a negative and it's crucial to use language that is deterministic.
There is a very real degree to which people are only capable of thinking clearly about complex systems to the degree they are comfortable with tools such as mathematics and programming that can be used to unambiguously describe them.