News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Yuzu emulator developers settle Nintendo lawsuit, pay $2.... by gjsman-1000 on Monday March 04, 2024 @02:12PM (#39594628)
You're assuming Nintendo doesn't file DMCA takedowns; especially considering they've literally just won a court case against it. And even if you are outside the US, I wouldn't be surprised if European service providers don't want to risk it because they are still under copyright treaties, of which the DMCA is just the US implementation.
Re:Yuzu emulator developers settle Nintendo lawsuit, pay $2.... by paol on Monday March 04, 2024 @02:26PM (#39594810)
I don't think it's that simple. For one thing emulation has been ruled legal in the US. By all reports Nintendo had an unusually strong case against Yuzu because the developers behind it didn't sufficiently distance themselves from piracy uses - the opposite if anything.

On the practical side, the fact that the developers were a for profit company also made Nintendo's job much easier.

Taking down a more legally careful, decentralized open source project should prove harder.

Re:Yuzu emulator developers settle Nintendo lawsuit, pay $2.... by gjsman-1000 on Monday March 04, 2024 @02:37PM (#39594938)
> For one thing emulation has been ruled legal in the US. By

Emulation was; breaking cryptographic locks under the DMCA never was. In addition, most of the pro-emulation lawsuits were decided before the relevant DMCA sections even came into effect (e.g. Bleem), and are quite possibly already obsolete.

Re:Yuzu emulator developers settle Nintendo lawsuit, pay $2.... by 1231232131231 on Monday March 04, 2024 @02:44PM (#39595024)
What if it was forked and the code that broke DRM was separated from the codebase, preferably as a library (dll/lib)?
Re:Yuzu emulator developers settle Nintendo lawsuit, pay $2.... by chaorace on Monday March 04, 2024 @03:46PM (#39595828)
In order to isolate one part of the software as "the bad bits", you need either clear specific language in the law or a clearly established relevant legal precedent. Neither of these things currently exist in the context of DMCA 1201.

If you're curious, here's the most relevant parts of the text:

> No person shall manufacture, import, offer to the public, provide, or otherwise traffic in any technology, product, service, device, component, or part thereof, that [...] has only limited commercially significant purpose or use other than to circumvent a technological measure that effectively controls access to a work protected under this title;[...]

> As used in this subsection—[...]a technological measure “effectively controls access to a work” if the measure, in the ordinary course of its operation, requires the application of information, or a process or a treatment, with the authority of the copyright owner, to gain access to the work.

FYI: I am not a lawyer, but you can listen to a lawyer explain the above at the following link https://youtu.be/wROQUZDCIMI?t=868

Re:Yuzu emulator developers settle Nintendo lawsuit, pay $2.... by colinsane on Monday March 04, 2024 @04:52PM (#39596621)
assuming you aren't a defendant in the above case, then the only ruling which would affect someone who wants to do this is (4):

> Developing or distributing software, including Yuzu, that in its ordinary course functions only when cryptographic keys are integrated without authorization, violates the Digital Millennium Copyright Act [...]

so, first reading, no: just taking Yuzu and splitting out the DRM stuff isn't legal if Yuzu still _depends_ on that DRM to function. you could maybe come up with some thing where you do full Switch emulation, with the code having literally zero concept of DRM/cryptography, and can only play homebrew games. do that and some other party would likely come around and do the (likely illegal) work to convert Switch games into a format your emulator understands. quite a bit like MAME cores, really.

fun speculating about how to bypass the spirit of this ruling though, huh? IMO if you actually want to do this don't bother with the roundabout. just do it directly and don't incorporate yourself in a state that cares about DMCA like a dumbass, and strictly distance your operations from your legal identity if you live under such a repressive regime.

Re:Yuzu emulator developers settle Nintendo lawsuit, pay $2.... by flykespice on Monday March 04, 2024 @05:55PM (#39597271)
> Taking down a more legally careful, decentralized open source project should prove harder.

Oh sweetheart, have you learnt about intimidation by legal fees? Doesn't matter whether it's legal or not, not many can bank to take against dedicated Nintendo legal team.

Re:Yuzu emulator developers settle Nintendo lawsuit, pay $2.... by hnfong on Monday March 04, 2024 @10:29PM (#39599116)
It's actually much harder for corporations to sue you if all they have on you is a github username.

But once you start taking "donations" and run the project like a business with non-trivial revenue, they can take you down easily by following the money trail.

Re:Yuzu emulator developers settle Nintendo lawsuit, pay $2.... by ip_addr on Monday March 04, 2024 @02:33PM (#39594892)
I wonder if takedowns like this will make decentralized code tools popular, for example: https://radicle.xyz/
Re:Yuzu emulator developers settle Nintendo lawsuit, pay $2.... by expert700 on Monday March 04, 2024 @03:06PM (#39595296)
They did not just win a court case though, they merely settled it outside of court; settling outside of court does not establish any legal precedent one way or another
Re:Yuzu emulator developers settle Nintendo lawsuit, pay $2.... by Narishma on Monday March 04, 2024 @06:37PM (#39597591)
They didn't settle outside of court.
Re:Yuzu emulator developers settle Nintendo lawsuit, pay $2.... by GabrielTFS on Monday March 04, 2024 @09:39PM (#39598836)
I don't see how it could establish legal precedent in a way that would be meaningfully useful to Nintendo in other court cases (well, I guess the fact the Yuzu devs settled could scare others into also doing so, but I mean in a legal sense)
Re:Yuzu emulator developers settle Nintendo lawsuit, pay $2.... by kevingadd on Monday March 04, 2024 @02:28PM (#39594840)
They can probably also compel the original copyright holders (the yuzu team) to issue takedowns of forks
Re:Yuzu emulator developers settle Nintendo lawsuit, pay $2.... by wtetzner on Monday March 04, 2024 @04:23PM (#39596319)
Given that it's under the GPL, I don't think they can do that.
Re:Yuzu emulator developers settle Nintendo lawsuit, pay $2.... by GardenLetter27 on Monday March 04, 2024 @02:55PM (#39595178)
On what grounds? They can't retroactively revoke the copyright licence previously granted no?
Re:Yuzu emulator developers settle Nintendo lawsuit, pay $2.... by kevingadd on Monday March 04, 2024 @03:57PM (#39595977)
You could probably contest the takedown on the basis that an open-source license allows you to post a fork, but Nintendo got them to agree that the content is illegal, so it seems questionable whether they could give you a license to distribute something it's no longer legal for them to distribute themselves. I wouldn't want to go to court over it, personally.
Re:Yuzu emulator developers settle Nintendo lawsuit, pay $2.... by Phrodo_00 on Monday March 04, 2024 @05:37PM (#39597086)
Nintendo did no such thing. They just settled out of court by owing enough money to bankrupt the company and agreeing to not distribute the work. It means nothing to other people that already have licenses to redistribute from earlier.
Re:Yuzu emulator developers settle Nintendo lawsuit, pay $2.... by GabrielTFS on Monday March 04, 2024 @09:41PM (#39598857)
People have a license under the GPL to redistribute Yuzu, and the devs know this - I don't think a settlement can compel them to commit perjury (which is what they would be doing if they knowingly lied in a DMCA takedown)
Re:Yuzu emulator developers settle Nintendo lawsuit, pay $2.... by snvzz on Monday March 04, 2024 @05:09PM (#39596810)
>especially considering they've literally just won a court case against it.

Wait what? When did this happen? Doesn't this story (about devs settling) mean the opposite of a court case being won or lost?

Re:Yuzu emulator developers settle Nintendo lawsuit, pay $2.... by kube-system on Monday March 04, 2024 @05:21PM (#39596937)
Out of court settlements are a thing, but this wasn't one. This was filed in-court. It's like the equivalent of a forfeit.

> Plaintiff Nintendo of America Inc. (“Plaintiff” or “Nintendo”) and Tropic Haze LLC (“Defendant” or “Tropic Haze”), by and through their undersigned counsel, hereby consent to judgment in favor of Nintendo, and jointly move the Court to enter monetary relief in the sum of US$2,400,000.00 in favor of Nintendo and against Defendant.

Translation:

"Hey court, we both agree that Nintendo wins, can we just skip the rest of this and mark this down as a win for them?"

Re:Yuzu emulator developers settle Nintendo lawsuit, pay $2.... by GabrielTFS on Monday March 04, 2024 @09:44PM (#39598880)
What's the distinction, then ? I can't imagine a company can set precedent to their liking on basically any issue by suing someone who has a vague relation to that issue and doesn't have to money to fight back to get them to sign up to some random settlement that says "the company is right, please set a precedent on this issue. - person who didn't have the money to fight back", right ?
Re:Yuzu emulator developers settle Nintendo lawsuit, pay $2.... by hnfong on Monday March 04, 2024 @10:34PM (#39599135)
It doesn't set a "precedent" in the strict legal sense, especially that there's no point of law being discussed.

But it does set a "precedent" in that when courts deal with similar cases in the future, they would look back and see the settlement, and it does influence a judges' assessment of whether Nintendo has a case or not, in the sense of "well, the defendants in the prior case forfeited, they must have had an open and shut case, right?"

In a perfect world where courts have all the time and resources to try a case, this shouldn't happen, but in practice courts use all sorts of heuristics (as long as they're not explicitly banned)...