I thought the function of fines WAS the deterrent effect? or is some aspect of this restitution? I thought this was payable to the EU itself, not spotify.
Maybe it's something akin to punative damages (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punitive_damages), where the "fine" component is assessed according to the actual harm measured and the "deterrent" amount is meant to make it sting as a punishment.
The law always needs a little something extra to deal with people like the guy who parks in handicap spaces because he can afford the fines.
In most cases, the Commission sets a fine which is based on the harm caused by some anti-competitive conduct, with relatively small adjustments for extenuating or attenuating circumstances. In this instance it's the opposite; the economic harm was small but the adjustment was huge.
You're right that the logic - deterrence - is the same in both cases. But what's different (at least in my view), is the object of the deterrence.
Ordinary fines are designed to make anti-competitive behaviour unattractive in terms of the costs and benefits. Maybe some underhanded conduct generates €40m extra profit, but the risk of a €40m fine plus legal costs and adjustments makes it not worth it.
The trouble is that these fines might are essentially just rounding errors for large firms. In this case, a €40m fine would be tiny in relation to Apple's revenue stream (~€350bn euros a year), thus not an effective deterrent. That's for two reasons. First, the 40m figure is too low since a "significant part of the harm caused by the infringement consists of non-monetary harm, which cannot be properly accounted for under the revenue-based methodology as set out in the [Commission's guidelines]"[1]. Second, the fine is trying to to "deter [Apple and] other companies of a similar size and with similar resources from committing the same or a similar infringement"[1] even when they could absorb the ordinary (small) fine as essentially a rounding error on their cost of doing business. In that case, large conglomerates could basically just ignore competition law.
So here, the Commission is deterring all firms which have a "particularly large turnover" [2] (e.g. Big Tech firms) from using their power in one market to gain an advantage in another market, as in this case where Apple used its control over its App Store to gain an advantage in the music streaming market. The fining guidelines allow for fines to be much larger (~50x in this case) for tech giants, even if the actual infringement didn't cause that much quantifiable harm.
You're right, there's no restitution here. As you say, the fine is payable to the EU and would be paid into the EU budget.
[1] https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_24_... [2] Para 30 https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/ALL/?uri=CELEX%3A...
Morally, if we fine violations to the speed limit in proportion to the context of the transgression only it will not adapt to the income of the transgressor. That makes it practically legal for rich people to drive as fast as they wish.
To function as a deterrent, it needs to represent a cost that a company is unwilling to tolerate.
Another way to think about it, is to say that we care about safeguarding the process of competition itself. That could include ensuring that competition is fair, ensuring that firms can enter markets, ensuring consumers get to choose which firms to consume from, etc. There's lots of precedent for that in EU competition law [1]. Taking that view, Apple was using its dominant position to restrict the economic freedom of Spotify (and others) and thereby harming the process of competition. Specifically, it limited rival firms from "fully informing iOS users about alternative and cheaper music subscription services" (as per the press release), thus harming competition.
All that to say, if we take the objective of EU competition law as being to prevent large firms from exercising power over smaller firms and to protect the process of competition in a general sense, then these big fines are easier to justify.
[1] https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3166005
I'd prefer if they could just jail the executives instead, but since sadly companies are an effective shield against justice this will have to do.
For an ageing but interesting case, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lysine_price-fixing_conspiracy
How is that "insane"?
It's pretty clear that Apple Music hadn't gone rogue.
So it deters nothing, Apple pays it and continues to do what it's doing.
GDPR rules follow the same structure and are a pretty good deterrent.
Uff. Spotify can ask for damage compensation on top of those 1.8 B€, huh?! Apart from music streaming services, I don't see why the situation isn't fundamentally the same with video streaming and Apple TV, and maybe even things like VPN, or cloud services, where Apple has its own competing products now.
So... this ultimately may get really, really nasty and expensive for Apple. I am so here for it :)
Well they don't give iPhones and App Store away for free.
Cheapest iPhones in Germany cost ~$530 for a 64GB model which Apple will nag you to subscribe to their iCloud to offload data.
Meanwhile developers need a $1k macbook (with measly 8GB RAM and 256GB storage btw) and $100/year.
And you get no choice to install from other app stores. So generous!
Luckily there's such thing as consumer protection laws in EU.
So my family can enjoy at least some protection from idiotic things such as not using industry standard charging cables (USB-C) while still marketing their product as green. And abusing their power against other companies and customers.
We're still left with jokes like a thousand dollar 8GB/256GB laptop sporting glued parts and an outdated 60hz screen (my friends 6year old phone has better screen refresh rate).
Not to mention they compare M3 performance against M1 instead of M2. There's only so much laws can do against deceiving marketing.
And maybe baby, you should also explore, if you may be affected by a cultural economic dogma founded in times of red scare propaganda. Because these naive free market takes tend to come up a bit reflexively in some people, but are actually very rare for economic scientists.
I just don't think its really necessary or high priority for iPhones. Android is one OS like Linux is one OS, there are 5-6 big time manufacturers with their own OSes, 100s of phones at all price points. I was replying to someone complaining about the price point but there are so many great phones at lower price points. Not to mention discounted rates on plans or second hand phones.
This particular case was about Apple not allowing third party payment options. The payment market is cornered by Visa/MasterCard that charges 1% on every single transaction. They charge a huge percent rate on a constant amount of work. There are countries that operate their own payment systems that have 0 or close to 0 fees on transactions. But no one is going to go after Visa/MC in a 2-player market just like phones that hasn't reduced prices in decades? So now Spotify can stop paying fees to one monopolist and pay them to the next one down the line? These don't look like rational, considered decisions by antitrust agencies to focus on the markets that have the worst behaviour, more just piling on the current thing.
No, you were replying to someone pointing out how much Apple already got paid for their product, the infrastructure and ecosystem entry, before rent seeking from Spotify.
> So now Spotify can stop paying fees to one monopolist and pay them to the next one down the line?
Are you serious? First off, the fees differ substantially, Visa/MC is likely involved in any case, and most importantly: That's not what this lawsuit is about at all. The antitrust dynamic comes with the fact that Apple has it's own competitive service going. Spotify can't even inform its customers about alternative payment options within the app.
Not to mention, mixing the end consumer choices with Spotify's choices now does not make a lot of sense as an argument to begin with.
That's what their customers payed for when they bought very expensive iDevices. Honestly, what a weird take, considering Apple really invented this argument. iOS app devs and service providers are just as much a necessity for Apple's popularity and success. You know, the default iOS calculator app used to be a meme not that long ago...
> Appstore
Yeah really, unhappy devs should totally roll their own distribution like on every other platform since the beginning of software development. Oh, wait...
> But you know, everyone wants a piece of the cake Apple thought they baked under their own terms.
Or maybe, Apple wanting a piece of the second largest consumer market should play by its rules, considering all the commerce infrastructure they are using... Not to mention the education system they are free-riding for their engineers, courts protecting their brand and IP, police enforcing property rights, ...
Do you pay taxes in Jonestown?
We should read the 1.8bn lump sum (roughly 0.5% of Apple's revenue) as partially being about music streaming and app stores, but mainly a warning to all large firms which are currently jockeying for a dominant position in emerging tech like generative AI and visual computing.
The warning: play fair and compete on the merits, or see you in court.
[1] "the Commission decided to add to the basic amount of the fine an additional lump sum of €1.8 billion to ensure that the overall fine imposed on Apple is sufficiently deterrent" https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_24_... [2] See paras 30 and 31. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/ALL/?uri=CELEX%3A...