News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US prescription market hamstrung for 9 days (so far) by r... by gustavus on Saturday March 02, 2024 @11:31PM (#39578435)
The problem is not that the ransomware attackers attacked. It's the fact that $10 says they've been systematically underinvesting in security and nows it's biting them in the a*. But it doesn't matter because they've basically managed to be come a monopoly through acquisitions and using the bludgeon of government regulation to ensure no competition occurs.

The next step is to move to declare this critical national infrastructure and create all sorts of new obtuse rules and regulations that will be in the name of security, but will mostly be theater and whose only real effect will be to create tons of new "compliance" jobs by low skilled morons who couldn't cut it in a real security job and whose primary job will be preventing actual security and sapping energy from anyone who builds things, because "it's not on the checklist".

Not to mention the dozens of new vendors who will pop up soliciting a product that will promise to ensure customers are in complaince with the new regulations.

Meanwhile Joe blow will still be unable to get his prescription filled and have his personal health data stolen and sold all over the black market.

Re:US prescription market hamstrung for 9 days (so far) by r... by Veserv on Sunday March 03, 2024 @12:11AM (#39578590)
There is literally no point to "investing" in modern commercial IT cybersecurity. It is all a bunch of useless junk that is incompatible with creating systems with any meaningful security. The big banks are spending hundreds of millions to billions of dollars a year on that junk and their cybersecurity teams know they can not even stop small teams with a million dollar budget. Literal kids fresh out of college at the banks manage more money than that.

That is literally the case across all industries in every field in every area with big tech being no exception. Almost certainly everybody you have heard about does not and has never had the slightest clue on how to protect against economically motivated, professional criminals; the kinds of attackers that are now commonplace and are expected to attack every commercial system in the modern threat landscape.

This is not a problem of underinvestment, it is a problem of structural incompetence. Systems need to verifiably survive red team pentests with multi-million dollar budgets with exactly zero discovered vulnerabilities before we are even in range of reasonable solutions. Any standard lower than that is inadequate to demonstrate resistance to commonplace attacks and is not even worth discussing.

Re:US prescription market hamstrung for 9 days (so far) by r... by adamsb6 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @01:30AM (#39578938)
There are two kinds of security.

Nearly all of corporate America practices security by checklist and certification. This is not real security, it’s just CYA for careerists and legal challenges.

Actual security is hard and almost no one does it. The people capable of it are rare and expensive. They’re probably not jumping at the opportunity to work at Optum for $80,000.

Re:US prescription market hamstrung for 9 days (so far) by r... by Veserv on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:10AM (#39579094)
And who does actual security? Certainly not Google, Apple, Microsoft, Palo Alto Networks, Crowdstrike, etc. If that is who you were going to bring up, none of those companies has ever developed and deployed a usable system secure against even middling adversaries with only a few million dollars of budget.

You will find exactly zero people at those companies who would be willing to bet their job that a small team of say 3-5 skilled offensive specialists specifically targeting them and willing to expend a year of fulltime work (i.e. a few million dollars worth of personnel cost) would not be able to completely compromise any usable system they designed.

Exactly zero of the recognized names can protect against economically-motivated professional criminals targeting you. All they even claim to do is make you the ROI of attacking you go from the industry average of 100x to a still wildly profitable 10x under the "You don't need to be faster than the hunters, you just need to be faster than the other dodos" theory. Unfortunately, that theory does not work when the hunters keep bringing more of their friends to eat mouth-watering dodos. I mean, the cyberattacks have only been increasing by like, 500% YoY for the last 10 years. Exponential growth that slow means you can keep outrunning the hunters for like 5-10 more years until they eat everybody.

Re:US prescription market hamstrung for 9 days (so far) by r... by klabb3 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @06:51AM (#39580269)
This economic projection-simplification doesn’t sound right to me.

Even if $1M gets you a successful attack, doesn’t mean that the next $1M will. A strong security culture patches up holes and reduces the surface area and damage radius over time.

I agree there’s a ton of snake oil. Most of it is. I agree that actors like Google and Apple also have 0days and will continue to have them. However, there’s still a massive difference between not giving a shit and a strong security posture. Some industries (most?) are in the former camp. They’re the ones who grinds to a halt from WannaCry and friends.

Re:US prescription market hamstrung for 9 days (so far) by r... by Veserv on Sunday March 03, 2024 @04:37PM (#39584751)
If the audit was only run once as a exploratory measure, then you are correct, but that is not the case. If you run a audit intended to detect defects at the 1 M$ level 10 times and literally every single time you find truckloads of defects then you have statistical evidence on the quality of your processes.

As a simpler example, suppose you did a firing test of a bulletproof vest and the bullet went right through. They patch that up and then you fire again and it goes right through. They do that 10 times and literally every single time it goes right through. You can conclude that those failures were not a fluke, their bulletproof vest is just garbage.

To use a slightly more complex variant, suppose they had bulletproof vest version 1 and during acceptance testing the bullet goes right through. They go back to the drawing board and produce bulletproof vest version 2 claiming it is bulletproof and then the bullet goes right through again. They do this 10 times and literally every time they claimed it was bulletproof and every time the bullet goes right through. You can conclude that their engineering or validation processes are garbage and, additionally, you can only trust them as far as you can throw them. Until they conclusively demonstrate robust protection against bullets in representative tests their products and "expertise" should be ignored.

The thing in the cybersecurity industry is that they fail the audit every time across all fields across all products across all systems. This is not a one-off case where a company has never done it before and they failed once so it might be a fluke or they can improve. This is everybody doing thousands of audits each and literally every single one of them has never once demonstrated a defect rate better than the low M$ range no matter how many changes or "improvements" they make. And the entire time they have been issuing deceptive marketing making people think they can. That is about as clear cut statistical evidence of industry-wide quality control failures as you can find in any field.

Just for reference, this is extremely abnormal in other industries. Only in cybersecurity and software are poor quality control and validation processes so rampant that obvious global process failures are viewed as just the way things are done. Yes, some parts of the software industry are even worse, but even the "best" parts are laughably inadequate. Engineering is not about subjective evaluations like better, it is about objective evaluations like fit for purpose. And commercial IT cybersecurity fails that with a resounding no.

Re:US prescription market hamstrung for 9 days (so far) by r... by klabb3 on Monday March 04, 2024 @08:10AM (#39590017)
Thanks for following up.

I agree, however say Google and Apple have very few of these despite being disproportionately targeted. Doesn’t mean they are doing enough. But it sure as hell makes a difference. In ~15 years my gmail has never been leaked or hacked. That’s better than having an unprotected DB leaking every customers credit score, like we’ve seen.

Certainly this audit-, certification- and checklist based security is a joke. Security isn’t a patch-work. It’s not separable from software development, and cannot be a separate process/workstream either (a thousand faint gasps ring out from middle managers across the enterprise world).

Anyway, I’m rambling. I guess I wanted to say that I’m optimistic for the long term. We’ve already made some significant progress in the last 10 years, for the better. I expect that to continue slowly.

Re:US prescription market hamstrung for 9 days (so far) by r... by ethbr1 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @12:07AM (#39578576)
> $10 says they've been systematically underinvesting in security and nows it's biting them in the a*. But it doesn't matter because they've basically managed to become a monopoly [...]. The next step is to move to declare this critical national infrastructure and create all sorts of new obtuseness rules and regulations [...]

There really only need to be 3 for critical infrastructure.

#1 - Patch your shit according to industry standards, and have documented audit records that you've done that in a timely manner.

#2 - You're fair game for NSA and DoD offensive pen testing. Failed pen tests are responsibility disclosed, then reported to the market after delay.

#3 - So goes CISO, so goes CEO. Along with a ban from leadership roles for a number of years (5?).

The issue is that the CEOs of these companies hire fall-on-your-sword guy as CISO, ignore the issues / listen to their CISO glossing over deficiencies, then claim breaches came out of nowhere, fire the CISO, and repeat business as usual.

It's not going to change until CEOs have a realistic expectation that deficiencies will be found and personal consequences when they are.

Re:US prescription market hamstrung for 9 days (so far) by r... by easyas124 on Saturday March 02, 2024 @11:34PM (#39578445)
Somehow we need to make Joe Blow a profiteering, parasitic middleman, then maybe regular people can finally benefit like everyone else in this disgusting system.