Re:Could Modified Gravity Kill Planet Nine?
by isthatafact on Saturday March 02, 2024 @05:24PM
(#39576305)
There is no DNA for galaxies, so how could you know what the properties of a particular galaxy "should be"?
The focus on "per-galaxy parameters" is like expecting to be able to predict how tall Tom Cruise should be after reading a textbook on the theory of evolution.
Re:Could Modified Gravity Kill Planet Nine?
by throwawaymaths on Sunday March 03, 2024 @01:35PM
(#39583084)
Ok so you are admitting that just as evolution is a poor model for human height, DM is a poor model for galaxy rotation curves.
Re:Could Modified Gravity Kill Planet Nine?
by isthatafact on Monday March 04, 2024 @03:02PM
(#39595254)
Maybe my metaphor was too sloppy to illustrate the point, but I do not follow your logic here at all.
That's what I mean by "it's a per-galaxy parameter". For each galaxy, to explain the behavior of that galaxy, you're saying "it must have X amount of dark matter".