News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple reverses course on death of Progressive Web Apps in EU by smoldesu on Friday March 01, 2024 @12:22PM (#39564080)
The fear of low-profitability is what drives that behavior, though. You're right that the DMA/DSA threatens Apple's bottom line, but as long as Apple continues to sell iPhone hardware in Europe then they should be turning a profit on hardware margins alone. Apple wants the control at any cost, and it's going to encourage more countries to draft even stronger legislation.
Re:Apple reverses course on death of Progressive Web Apps in EU by Zak on Friday March 01, 2024 @12:29PM (#39564199)
I'm surprised the EU appears to be letting them get away with charging a fee for apps installed outside the app store.
Re:Apple reverses course on death of Progressive Web Apps in EU by albert180 on Friday March 01, 2024 @01:04PM (#39564670)
The DMA goes into force only tomorrow. We will see if they will get away. I guess they will get bonked, because they apply more favourable conditions for their own App Store. They might get away if they would charge the fee for all Developers, but the Bullshit with "staying inside the old conditions" will surely get them into trouble
Re:Apple reverses course on death of Progressive Web Apps in EU by threeseed on Friday March 01, 2024 @12:44PM (#39564383)
Most companies e.g. Unreal charge a fee for using their SDKs.

The idea that you would be forced to give it away for nothing would be a pretty extraordinary and unworkable intervention in the market.

Re:Apple reverses course on death of Progressive Web Apps in EU by Zak on Friday March 01, 2024 @12:53PM (#39564511)
They can charge licensing fees for their SDKs, but the "core technology fee" is not structured that way. As currently structured, it would apply even to an app written from scratch in ARM assembly language (not that a reasonable person would build an iPhone app that way).
Re:Apple reverses course on death of Progressive Web Apps in EU by threeseed on Friday March 01, 2024 @01:17PM (#39564824)
CLI apps are not supported on iOS.

So at some point you have to interact with Apple SDKs.

Re:Apple reverses course on death of Progressive Web Apps in EU by Zak on Friday March 01, 2024 @01:30PM (#39565016)
Making system/library calls to display something on the screen does not necessarily require the use of an SDK either; it might require quite a bit of reverse engineering work. As far as I understand copyright, that doesn't involve copying/distributing the library code and wouldn't be legally encumbered unless there's a patent covering it.
Re:Apple reverses course on death of Progressive Web Apps in EU by justinclift on Friday March 01, 2024 @02:53PM (#39566043)
The fee kills any real world possibility of an OSS App Store though.

1 million downloads for an app sounds like a lot for a paid app.

But on the desktop, popular OSS software packages do those kind of numbers in well under a year. There's no reason to believe OSS mobile apps on iPhone would be any different.

Re:Apple reverses course on death of Progressive Web Apps in EU by threeseed on Friday March 01, 2024 @03:21PM (#39566348)
Non-profit organisations are exempt from the core technology fee.
Re:Apple reverses course on death of Progressive Web Apps in EU by justinclift on Friday March 01, 2024 @04:25PM (#39566975)
Cool, that might make it workable then. :)
Re:Apple reverses course on death of Progressive Web Apps in EU by kmeisthax on Friday March 01, 2024 @05:47PM (#39567732)
Unreal is a game engine, iOS is an operating system.

In almost every other case application software is not considered to be a derivative work of the operating system it runs on. If this wasn't the case, then Apple could have easily sued Cydia and AltStore for offering the equivalent of iOS fanfiction. Hell, even the Copyright Office was perfectly fine with adding a DMCA 1201 exemption for jailbreaking iPhones to install non-Apple software on them - and they're extremely tightfisted with those.

The reasons why this is different is very simple: you don't distribute Apple's SDK along with your application, but you do distribute Unreal's. The user got access to Apple's code when they bought their iPhone, you have to give them Unreal Engine, so you need a license for that.

Re:Apple reverses course on death of Progressive Web Apps in EU by disgruntledphd2 on Friday March 01, 2024 @12:40PM (#39564341)
They haven't hit the deadline yet, lobby your national and EU representatives if you want rid of this.
Re:Apple reverses course on death of Progressive Web Apps in EU by roamerz on Friday March 01, 2024 @12:43PM (#39564371)
>The fear of low-profitability is what drives that behavior

Are you sure about that? Seems like a pretty bold statement where you would have to have some kind of inside information.

I don't have anything to substantiate this but I would like to believe that Apple still has the best interest of it's customers and security in mind when fighting these kinds of legislation. I switched from Android to Apple BECAUSE of those restrictions and the improved security the walled garden model provides. The other reason was the middle finger Apple gave to the cell providers about applying firmware updates to their phones. When I was using Android it was maddening to wait months for an update to be 'approved' and able to install. That led me to rooting and installing firmware that was outside of the manufactures control and who knows what might have been in that.

So for me everything that Apple does to keep a walled garden is what actually keeps me as a customer and helps their bottom line.

Re:Apple reverses course on death of Progressive Web Apps in EU by Zak on Friday March 01, 2024 @01:00PM (#39564601)
It does not seem to me that anything about the DMA will make it difficult for people who prefer to stay inside Apple's walled garden to do so. Most Android users only install apps from the Play Store and use Chrome as their browser.
Re:Apple reverses course on death of Progressive Web Apps in EU by smoldesu on Friday March 01, 2024 @03:00PM (#39566126)
> Are you sure about that?

Certain as I can be, without having seen the cards. Apple is a company about margins; you see it in their hardware profitability, but also in Tim Cook's service initiative. They fought Dutch regulators over this for months preceding the regulation, and it's not a stretch to say the DMA and DSA is a direct legislative response to Apple's wanton behavior.

Apple can move literal mountains, when it aligns with their incentive of increasing profit margins. Anything that falls outside that purview ends up sidelined or worse-yet, lobbied against.

> So for me everything that Apple does to keep a walled garden is what actually keeps me as a customer and helps their bottom line.

That's great, and Apple has every right to provide you a differentiated experience. I've been a historical Apple customer, and I still keep a Magic Trackpad around because it's mostly quite good.

But you and I aren't entitled to a sustained monopoly because it benefits us. Happy IE users or Bell Telephone customers aren't an argument against antitrust action, and it's ultimately entirely tangential to how legal they are.

Consider how Apple behaves in hardware, sponsoring dubious Chinese labor to make shareholders happy. They set industry-leading profit margins by sparing no expense in their exploitation of labor and parts manufacturing. Is it legal? They say so. But of course Apple would, and they have no incentive to ever stop the squeeze if shareholders cheer them on. They will behave just as insidiously with software, and if you do not treat their every action with that scrutiny then you'll pave the road to hell with good intentions.

I want businesses to be good people. I want God to run a killer froyo stand. But men are fickle, and Apple has been a swindling bastard of a company ever since Jobs cheated Woz out of $4,500 over an Atari contract.

Re:Apple reverses course on death of Progressive Web Apps in EU by roamerz on Friday March 01, 2024 @04:57PM (#39567262)
> But you and I aren't entitled to a sustained monopoly because it benefits us.

Does 20.1 percent market share constitute a monopoly?(2023 Forbes) Seems like people have plenty of choices of what kind of cell phone to purchase.

>treat their every action with scrutiny

Is that not what the free market does? When companies make poor choices customers punish them. (Budweiser 2023)

Re:Apple reverses course on death of Progressive Web Apps in EU by kmeisthax on Friday March 01, 2024 @05:56PM (#39567814)
The issue isn't the size of Apple's market share, it's the tying between their hardware, the OS software, and app store, such that if you choose to buy their phone, you also are locked into their app store.

Apple is not subject to market forces because Apple is not a capitalist entity, it is a feudalist one. It is not a merchant buying metal and glass to turn into phones, it is a feudal lord that has put a gate on the river that anyone passing buy has to pay 30% in order to open.

Re:Apple reverses course on death of Progressive Web Apps in EU by simondotau on Friday March 01, 2024 @08:43PM (#39569034)
> if you choose to buy their [device], you also are locked into their [software ecosystem].

Other than desktop computing, this describes nearly everything sold to consumers. For people in the Hacker News audience, desktop computing would feel like a gargantuan exception, but for most other people it isn't. Android is a partial exception, but one gets the sense from Google's recent behaviour that openness is an unwelcome vestige of its open source beginnings.

Re:Apple reverses course on death of Progressive Web Apps in EU by smoldesu on Friday March 01, 2024 @08:55PM (#39569092)
It's not an exception. Binary distribution is the norm - Apple founded their business on that norm, found success in it, fostered it and continues to support it on MacOS. The App Store style of distribution is not a replacement for it, especially when the escape hatches for developers cost an annual fee and still has limitations. If it takes legislation to change that, so be it. This is not the future for computing that anyone wanted.

If there's a good reason iOS can't run third-party software, now's the time to fix it. Otherwise, Apple might have to find a new economic zone to invest in.

Re:Apple reverses course on death of Progressive Web Apps in EU by simondotau on Saturday March 02, 2024 @04:35PM (#39575978)
If your life revolves around desktop computers, I can see why you would think it’s the norm.
Re:Apple reverses course on death of Progressive Web Apps in EU by smoldesu on Saturday March 02, 2024 @05:59PM (#39576578)
Apple themselves distributed software as a binary before they had an App Store. If there was some other "norm" to speak of, it didn't exist when the Apple IIc hit shelves.
Re:Apple reverses course on death of Progressive Web Apps in EU by simondotau on Sunday March 03, 2024 @01:59AM (#39579052)
Correct, it didn't exist back then, because just about the only software a consumer would ever be exposed to was some kind of desktop computer. The closed model got its early start in the nineties when it became increasingly common for consumer devices to include software in their design.

Among the earliest examples of this emerging new normal in its gestational phase would be game consoles from the 16-bit era onwards. It also included just about all pre-smart cellular phones (but for occasional a rather pointless Java support), nearly all printers, nearly all camcorders, and so on. There are probably between 5 and 50 internet connected "computers" in the typical home and the typical consumer has some semblance of software control on maybe three of them.

Re:Apple reverses course on death of Progressive Web Apps in EU by smoldesu on Sunday March 03, 2024 @11:09AM (#39581748)
Game consoles defend their software ecosystem because they don't have hardware margins (unlike Apple). Apple could try to use the console manufacturer defense, but they'd have to abandon their biggest cash cow to make it work.

> nearly all printers, nearly all camcorders, and so on.

I'm really starting to think nobody here read the Digital Service Act. Unless your toaster or smart-refrigerator is a gatekeeper platform with the required number of users, it doesn't matter. Apple is rightfully being called out for anticompetitive conduct, regardless of how you feel about the morality of an App Store.

If App Stores are the future, we'll have to Think Different and implement them in better way. Apple has their work cut out for them, the preemptive apologism falls on deaf ears.

Re:Apple reverses course on death of Progressive Web Apps in EU by smoldesu on Friday March 01, 2024 @06:07PM (#39567907)
> Does 20.1 percent market share constitute a monopoly?

Depends how it's used. Wabash v. Illinois set the precedent that a far-minority can be a monopoly if they block a government-designated common carrier. Europe's DMA doesn't even mention monopolies at all, and instead sets a new compliance bar for large tech-related companies. Japan's legislation is headed in the same direction.

Seems entirely feasible to me that the App Store or Safari policies could be seen as obstruction of a common service. Apple's de-facto tax hasn't been explicitly blocked in the US yet, but it also has never been explicitly sanctioned. Without guidelines like the DMA in place, Apple is flying blind against US regulators. Microsoft got trapped deep in that hall of mirrors, and nearly paid the ultimate price.

> Is that not what the free market does?

The free market is supplanted by a government that ensures that only a non-lethal portion of rat feces is processed into your container of SPAM or McDonalds meal. They prevent you from exposure to what businesses call, "profit maximization".

If you have a good government, they treat you a little better. They punish the companies that violate consumer rights and scrutinize anticompetitive behavior when it shows up. The free market chooses between regulated competitors; if you think that's unfair, you can move to a country without the rat-feces regulators and see how your breakfast tastes over there. Then we can all be happy.

> When companies make poor choices customers punish them. (Budweiser 2023)

Your evidence is proof to the contrary of your claim. Budweiser wasn't "punished" for making an anticompetitive move, they were boycott because insecure Budweiser customers had a slow news cycle. If Apple had customers protesting for the same reasons, they'd never even know.

"Poor choices" notwithstanding, Apple customers couldn't be assed if they were angry. Suicide nets go up at Foxconn and the harshest words HN or MacRumors can muster is 'poor choice of manufacturing partner'. Conscientious startups and their Macbooks, nary separated any easier than protesting trailer parks and Budweiser.

Re:Apple reverses course on death of Progressive Web Apps in EU by albert180 on Friday March 01, 2024 @01:03PM (#39564657)
Yeah, who knows what's inside of OpenSource Firmware like LineageOS. It's a huge mystery

Also I never needed to wait for a carrier to approve an Update for my Android Phone. Neither for my Pixel, Nexus or Samsung Galaxy ones.

And beside the "strict" controls, malicious Apps got in the App Store, and the iPhones themselves also pwned.

Are there other Apple Fanboy Horror Stories about Android that you've missed?