News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Richard Stallman Collapses At Barcelona Conference by mindcrime on Thursday May 10, 2012 @05:22PM (#3956120)
It can't be, because if it's a fundamental right (read: entitlement) then someone else is obligated to provide that care. So, in a hypothetical world where no one chooses to go into the medical profession, we'd have to put guns to people's heads and force them to become doctors, because, after all, medical care is a "fundamental right." There's an obvious paradox in that.

Medical care is a "right" in the sense that it's something you shouldn't have to ask for permission to seek, but we aren't entitled to it. It's a service that can be provided and bought on the free market like all other services.

Re:Richard Stallman Collapses At Barcelona Conference by icebraining on Thursday May 10, 2012 @06:15PM (#3956420)
That argument is perfect in a theoretical world where no one choose to go into the medical profession. Back in real life, that doesn't happen. At most, you have to hire foreign doctors. So yes, it's a right, which like any other right, it's subject to the constraints of reality.
Re:Richard Stallman Collapses At Barcelona Conference by mindcrime on Thursday May 10, 2012 @06:34PM (#3956501)
Real world / hypothetical world / thought-experiment aside, the point stands: treating a service as an entitlement entails imposing an obligation on somebody else to provide that service, OR to pay for that service, etc.

If granting one person a "right" means violating someone else's rights (that is, their right to choose how to direct their energy and the fruits of their labor) then it's unjust.

Re:Richard Stallman Collapses At Barcelona Conference by icebraining on Thursday May 10, 2012 @06:44PM (#3956547)
I don't think it's unjust to make people contribute to society through taxes if they want to live in it. They're free to opt-out from that implicit contract by going to live elsewhere. There's plenty of inhabited places on Earth still.

In any case, rights can and are sometimes eclipsed by others. The idea of natural, absolute rights is just ridiculous.

Re:Richard Stallman Collapses At Barcelona Conference by cglace on Friday May 11, 2012 @09:45AM (#3959136)
"They're free to opt-out from that implicit contract by going to live elsewhere."

Is it your position that everything can be justified by a persons ability to get up and move?

Re:Richard Stallman Collapses At Barcelona Conference by icebraining on Saturday May 12, 2012 @08:43AM (#3963678)
No, just some.
Re:Richard Stallman Collapses At Barcelona Conference by mindcrime on Friday May 11, 2012 @12:18AM (#3957617)
I respectfully disagree, but this really isn't the forum for this discussion, so I'll bow out here.
Re:Richard Stallman Collapses At Barcelona Conference by runningdogx on Friday May 11, 2012 @06:55AM (#3958591)
Yeah, I think me_myselft meant rights in terms of social justice, and not "fundamental rights" in the sense of abstract political philosophy. So many arguments get caught up over semantics and not what people are trying to say.
Re:Richard Stallman Collapses At Barcelona Conference by el_presidente on Thursday May 10, 2012 @06:24PM (#3956456)
> It's a service that can be provided and bought on the free market like all other services.

Maybe in a hypothetical world where you can find this hypothetical free market. In the real world, health care can be treated as a fundamental right because there are enough doctors available.

Re:Richard Stallman Collapses At Barcelona Conference by CamperBob2 on Thursday May 10, 2012 @06:49PM (#3956572)
Try making those doctors work for free, and see how long there are "enough doctors available."
Re:Richard Stallman Collapses At Barcelona Conference by icebraining on Thursday May 10, 2012 @06:52PM (#3956587)
And we would do that... why?
Re:Richard Stallman Collapses At Barcelona Conference by CamperBob2 on Thursday May 10, 2012 @06:55PM (#3956595)
Either the doctors will have to work for free, or the rest of us will, to pay for others' health care.
Re:Richard Stallman Collapses At Barcelona Conference by harshreality on Friday May 11, 2012 @05:58AM (#3958460)
We pay for lots of services that only other people end up using. It's part of being in a society.

When something is reasonably considered optional, ideally and hopefully you aren't forced to pay for other people's partaking of that optional service.

Healthcare is not one of those things. It's optional in the sense that everyone has the option of refusing medical care, even if sometimes that means dying, but it's not optional in that almost every sane person with more than a minor cut or sniffles or food poisoning opts for medical care if it is available rather than the alternative.

Other mandatory goods and services, like food, clothing, housing, city utilities (water/electricity), even internet access, work better in a mostly private model for a couple major reasons. First, the price variance for the necessary part of those goods and services is very low compared to variance for the medical costs someone might incur. Second, a lot of people can afford and want more than the bare necessities. Not so with medical care, where few people can afford major surgery or routine treatments for some major chronic conditions.

Another aspect of medical care is that we benefit even if we're never treated. Do you know anyone who has ever needed significant medical care at a hospital? I doubt your relationship with those people means nothing to you.

Re:Richard Stallman Collapses At Barcelona Conference by icebraining on Thursday May 10, 2012 @07:28PM (#3956705)
We don't work for free, we work in exchange for the privilege of living in society.