The greed of the company owners/directors/management is preventing them from expanding
You're saying the same thing, but blaming different people. But keep in mind that economic systems that blame owners of capital for everything, and place extraordinary burdens on them, have not historically been very good economic systems.
Obviously the law is producing unintended consequences if France is full of 49 person companies who only exist to skirt some regulation.
This is why I say the effects matter not the intent. The effect is--companies are expanding less and hiring less workers.
Whether that is caused by greed or not is moot. If the law didn't exist the companies would expand, since it does exist they won't. The motives of the company are irrelevant.
The end result of this law will be less economic growth for France. If the desire is to build a social safety net, why not tax some of the extra economic gain that will result from fewer labor regulations and give the money to the people directly?
It happened to me and I have no hard feelings about it at all.
Without the requirement that 49-worker-plus enterprises have worker councils, most employers would squash them if at all possible, and there would be no one to negotiate humane layoff terms for the people being jettisoned.
I don't understand why a severance package should be something subject to negotiation.
Write a law with a very simple function of years of service, pay and age and let that spit out a number. Done. No time and money wasted negotiating, employers and employees know what they're getting.
When I was let off in 2009, I basically wasted 4 or 5 months at my old job waiting to get fired because the law required that much time for a collective termination. The outcome of that "negotiation" was not different than it was at day one, so I just don't get it.
The can't-shed-employees meat of the article is:
You have a company that shed a third of its workers. A workers' council fought for and managed to win a more favorable layoffs scheme for them than the employer would have liked but they were still layoffs. ["voluntary departure plan" is a terribly Orwellian name for a layoffs scheme] The company seems to have justified the layoffs as a matter of economic survival rather than claiming that a third of the workers that had been carefully screened, interviewed, and hired were actually no-good bums. It turns out that sales are now up 18%.If they were great, skilled employees regretfully laid off out of economic necessity then why not hire them back now that business has taken a turn for the better?
The answer would seem to be that the company was not honest about their reasons for the layoffs. Either they used an excuse to rid themselves of undesirables and low-performers or they used the economy as an excuse to fire otherwise fine workers.