The problem with such stringent firing laws is that they only give security to the people who are currently employed. However, they do not necessarily benefit the society, i.e. new workers won't be hired when they're needed, and companies won't expand, and the economy won't develop as rapidly, simply because it's too hard to fire someone when you don't need them anymore.
Maybe the details don't work out well. Perhaps 50 is too small. There are probably other issues in the details, but in principle, it seems interesting and useful.
That's an interesting idea, but mostly unnecessary - in most economies, the majority of the economic output is produced by "small companies" (including contract workers), so such incentive does not seem to be needed.
And if it were needed, you shouldn't encourage the existence of small companies by preventing the successful companies from growing larger, but by enabling entrepreneurs with setting up new companies without much hustle! By effectively imposing a limit on the company size, you just incentivize business owners to bundle up a bunch of small companies (as you correctly noticed in your original post), however, that is a purely bureaucratic dead-weight cost to the employer, and therefore to the employees and to the society, that produces no actual value, only takes it away! No wonder lawyers thrive in this environment!
Take toy manufacturers for example. They must send there products to an independent lab to have it certified lead free. The guy in his basement making kid size rocking chairs and selling 50 per year has a much harder time paying this, than Mattel. The end result is a tend towards larger companies who can better handle the regulatory burden.
Your fact contradicts your point. Productivity-per-worker is enormously higher in small companies. If a country could get all its workers working in small companies rather than most of them wasting their abilities in large companies, imagine how much more productive it would be.
>By effectively imposing a limit on the company size, you just incentivize business owners to bundle up a bunch of small companies (as you correctly noticed in your original post), however, that is a purely bureaucratic dead-weight cost to the employer, and therefore to the employees and to the society, that produces no actual value, only takes it away!
Successful companies would just go ahead and actually split into smaller companies - unless you're scrambling for every cent, the costs of the duplication involved are pretty minimal, and the benefits can be huge as the income from more successful projects is reinvested rather than being used to prop up failing ones. It may hasten the demise of some zombies, but that's no bad thing.
Also, 5000 workers might be less efficient (per head) than 50, but at least you know that if 10 are missing (sick leave/vacation/...) at any given time, your production will continue uninterrupted.
Growth seems to be the measure of success, both for investors and entrepreneurs, so I don't see this stopping any time soon. But imagine a world where, once companies got to the 20-50 person stage, they started paying dividends rather than expanding. There are probably other limiting factors, but if everyone was working in such a company and they were as successful as they are now, productivity would skyrocket.
Hell, even the IT department has gone this route where your division has to license an exchange or IMAP server through the IT department.
A few advantages, off the top of my head:
* more market diversity (e.g. more niche offerings)
* less consolidation of power (e.g. Apple / Oracle / Google / Microsoft, etc)
* more social incentive to reduce corporate-to-corporate transaction costs
* improved specialization
* increased competition
* development of new market sectors
Currently, small companies don't work as well as big ones because of the transaction cost overhead. It seems to me that if a society could reduce transaction costs between corporations, better services and more specialization could emerge.
In my experience, small groups are more agile and able to do an incredible amount of work. Why do you need 1,000 - 100,000 people in one company?
There's also nothing stopping the companies from outsourcing non-core work to other 49-person companies. Seems like there's a lot of market opportunities that entrepreneurs aren't taking.