News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You, Too, Can Be on the Cutting Edge of Functional Progra... by noelwelsh on Thursday May 10, 2012 @06:19AM (#3952682)
> No, but you're on the cutting edge of straw-man argumentation trivializing.

If only I was that good!

Research contributions generally have be novel AND significant. We have seen that novelty alone is not sufficient (sitting in the chair). Significant generally means applicable to a broad range of problems. Monads are significant, as one abstraction can encode a huge range of structures (containers, control flow, etc.) Building a game in Haskell is not a priori novel OR significant. People have done this before (e.g. http://www.haskell.org/haskellwiki/Frag). Haskell has good facilities for managing concurrency and state. It's not obvious to me that one would need to go beyond these to build a game. A game would probably need to bind to some C libraries but I don't see this as a significant contribution.

The original post made the following points:

- Writing a game in Haskell in novel (No. See above.)

- Writing a game in Haskell will generate significant contributions to the wider community. I don't see this.

Furthermore, it trivialised the accomplishments of both the functional programming community and those who really are on the cutting edge of research.

There are no comments on this comment yet.