News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Social Media First Amendment Cases by nradov on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @10:58AM (#39525594)
Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas has suggested that Congress consider extending Common Carrier legislation to cover online services. Essentially this would force them the allow all legal content, sort of like a telephone company.

https://www.npr.org/2021/04/05/984440891/justice-clarence-th...

Re:Social Media First Amendment Cases by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @11:05AM (#39525692)
If that happened what would the repercussions be?

I think they'd come together and create a certifying authority for authentic users with traceability. More compliance. Better filtering/admin tools for users.

Re:Social Media First Amendment Cases by icandoit on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @12:09PM (#39526534)
Would that mean that my poltical screeds (or spam) can't be deleted from your social media website for dogs?

That you would have continue to host and serve whatever content I publish? Even if your userbase only interacts with my content to hide it?

Re:Social Media First Amendment Cases by bilbo0s on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @11:53AM (#39526334)
No repercussions, because being a common carrier is voluntary.

What I mean is, you can have a members only club that is not a common carrier. For instance a member of the hypthetical video snippet network SnipWit can communicate only to other SnipWits. This means that SnipWit is not a common carrier. They are obviously private, as you can only communicate to other members. Worse yet, there is obviously consideration required prior to use, which means they would be able to add even more draconian terms to their membership requirements.

I'll give a hypothetical. CostCo is members only. You're not a member, you can't get groceries there. Full stop. It doesn't matter if it's the only grocer in your area, you'll have to drive to find a Kroger. And to illustrate what I mean by the ability to take things further, CostCo could add racial exclusivity requirements to their membership clauses. Blacks would then be barred from shopping there like they are barred from certain country clubs. And it would be totally legal and well within the rights of CostCo, those country clubs, or the hypothetical SnipWit. Why? Because these are all private organizations and members only.

I guess what I mean is, a lot of people talk about Common Carrier being the solution while forgetting about the private/public aspect and distinction at play in those regulations. We normally entice organizations to become common carriers by offering them goodies on the other side of that. Like indemnifications for instance. But what happens when you have organizations that are already fat, happy and growing like weeds under their "private with membership" umbrella? What do you offer them? It's a tough problem. There's a lot of people and shareholders making a lot of money in the current model. Those people will almost certainly vote their shares against becoming a common carrier unless there is more upside in it for them somehow.

Re:Social Media First Amendment Cases by nradov on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @01:29PM (#39527643)
You have misinterpreted the case law. Although Costco requires a membership to shop there, courts have generally found such places to be public accommodations rather than true private clubs. Thus, they would be legally barred from instituting a racial exclusivity requirement for membership. (I am only commenting on the strict legal issue here; obviously racial discrimination is morally wrong.)

https://www.cbsnews.com/minnesota/news/good-question-why-can...

Re:Social Media First Amendment Cases by nradov on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @11:16AM (#39525829)
I doubt it. That wouldn't provide any legal protection or cover to social media companies. Their main concern is with maintaining a positive brand image which keeps regular users and advertisers onboard. So, they don't want to host legal but offensive content that would decrease user engagement or drive advertisers away.

Forcing users to certify and authenticate themselves would drive a lot of users away and thus devastate advertising revenue. And many users will happily post offensive content using their real identities.

Re:Social Media First Amendment Cases by shadowgovt on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @04:23PM (#39530174)
Anyone who has been dealing with phone scams should have a healthy sense of dread on the idea that internet services should achieve parity of quality with phone service.