> In fact the requirement for domains and certificates has been always the single biggest hinderance, which inherently prevents self-hosted deployments in masses.
I'm confident that you never satisfactorily answered to that, and even more confident in my belief that such hinderance is inherent and thus should not be the foremost design factor. Unless you have a clear answer that can be universally applicable (that is, no "works for me and my friends", I too have enough technical friends who don't use Mastodon), please refrain from trying to claim otherwise.
This "conversation" has reached my threshold for puzzlement, so I'm dipping out. Let me show you how it feels to me with an analogy:
Some company is making a new revolutionary car. It gets about 10 miles of autonomy, can only turn right, and stalls every 100 feet. I point that out in the comments.
Then lifthrasiir shows up and says that some people have driven it successfully, that you can get anywhere by only turning right with careful planning, that most vehicles don't get a lot of autonomy only cars and trucks, that there are commercial services that will get the car where I need it to (by loading it on a truck), and anyway if I really want to get somewhere why don't I take a bus?
Sure, I never claimed that it couldn't be moved, or that it would prevent its owner from getting places. What I said is that it's a terrible car.
People are deploying Mastodon, it will keep being an actually-federated network, and Bluesky can be a centralized could-have-been federated network run by a couple of companies. But is that the goal as you see it?