News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Institutions try to preserve the problem to which they ar... by WalterBright on Monday February 26, 2024 @03:21AM (#39508760)
Why not take a look at the book? It's an easy read, and there's far too much of interest to quote here.

The religious angle is not relevant to this discussion. It's about the emergence of free markets in the Netherlands, and the results.

As for China, China invented a number of things, but failed to apply them like the West did. For one take on why, see the book "The Triumph of the West" by Roberts

https://www.amazon.com/triumph-West-J-M-Roberts/dp/076070850...

In modern times, China adopted free markets with spectacular results.

Re:Institutions try to preserve the problem to which they ar... by hef19898 on Monday February 26, 2024 @03:36AM (#39508865)
I don't know those specific books. I do know the pop-history trend of late that paints European dominance, starting in the 1500s and ending somewhere around WW1, in a certain way. Meaning Western capitalism, bonus points for including a religious angle, as the absolute superior. And that ignores a number of things:

It fails to look at the medival period as different, distinct periods. It also fails to brake those down by region. That can be called cherry picking.

It fails to look at all of that im context, especially by ommitting the history of the other side of Western dominance. That history is directly linked, after all Western dominance required a counter part to be dominated. So whatever happened at the other end is crucial to understand the shared history. This can be called ignorant.

And last but not least, this view on history is used to drive political narratives. As is the opposite political bias that shows in other books and papers. I do not like neither, historians shoupd at least try (one cannot be fully neutral ever) to be impartial and provide an objective study of history. Late pop-history doesn't do that.

Re:Institutions try to preserve the problem to which they ar... by WalterBright on Monday February 26, 2024 @01:13PM (#39514818)
> I don't know those specific books.

But you dismiss them anyway. I'm not impressed.