Re:'All of Us' genetics chart stirs unease over controversia...
by faeriechangling on Sunday February 25, 2024 @05:10PM
(#39505403)
Another observation is that if we ignore the existence of race AB, a person of race A with "mixed" genetics, and a person of race B with mixed genetics, may be closer to eachother genetically than other members of race A and B (since as you say, they're closer to race AB, not A or B).
Defining discrete categorisations for things that exist on a continuum is definitionally arbitrary and misleading.
Don't tell that to psychiatrists though, who do EXACTLY what is being criticised here and slap people who exist on a continuum with an arbitrary label, and yet the DSM-V is still taken seriously by the scientific mainstream.
Re:'All of Us' genetics chart stirs unease over controversia...
by kybernetikos on Sunday February 25, 2024 @05:02PM
(#39505314)
And this (and more) happened multiple times in effectively everyones ancestry.
Another common situation: People of race A think child 2 is race B, people of race B think child 2 is race A. And you can imagine more complex examples with more races and more generations. In this manner the categorization of race is primarily social.