The police might have thought that Sparkfun only sold credit card skimming machines. Hence asking for "all orders" doesn't sound as bad if you consider that they might be thinking that's only those parts.
This matches up with reality since they seem happen when Sparkfun talks to them and they agree to only get the details for that parts.
Re:SparkFun Gets A Subpoena
by InclinedPlane on Wednesday May 09, 2012 @04:24PM
(#3950302)
I suspect that the police in this case have no idea how big sparkfun is or how much business they do.
More likely, they just ask for everything in the hopes that they don't miss anything, and then rely on the targeted business to try to argue down the scope of the subpoena. The police have no incentive to try and limit the scope because they don't care about protecting the privacy of the people they're investigating.
Re:SparkFun Gets A Subpoena
by sirclueless on Thursday May 10, 2012 @05:00AM
(#3952464)
> they don't care about protecting the privacy of the people they're investigating.
That seems like an overbroad generalization. All else being equal, I'm sure the police don't want to compromise people's privacy. To be sure it's not their top priority, and if they had to choose between missing important data and dragging too many innocent people into an investigation they will probably err on the side of too much data.
Even if the police don't much care about privacy, there are a lot of people who do. For example, there's no way a court would let any of this subpoenaed evidence into the record unless it was specifically relevant to a charge being brought.
But I'm amazed their initial subpoena was for ALL orders from Georgia for a multi-month period. That's an amazingly wide net.