Re:Every model learned by gradient descent is approximately ...
by csomar on Sunday February 25, 2024 @07:06AM
(#39500117)
I wonder if cognition or intelligence is actually "brain damage". Your bad memory is leading to erroneous paths but some of these will eureka. Genetic evolution and natural selection are essentially that.
If your memory is too bad, then you are either insane or in an advanced state of Alzheimer. If you have enough stable paths to lead a quasi-normal life, then you become an inventor or an artist; or something atypical.
Hallucination is the feature, not the bug.
To be very reductive, an associative memory can hold a truth table. Put minimal state, IO and a loop around that and you have a universal Turing machine. Which is why the "it's just memory" or "it's just Markov chains" is so tedious - it says near nothing about the computational power of the system including the model.
There's plenty of reason, of course, to question to what extent we know the abilities of the models, but when people assume dismissing it as "memory" or "just statistics" or "just Markov chains" I usually take it as a signal they don't understand how few limitations that imposes.