News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Notes from an Interviewer by tptacek on Saturday February 24, 2024 @05:35PM (#39495750)
Interviewing is a terrible way to screen candidates, but if you're literally asking questions that appear on "top 10 interview questions" pages, you're not even trying.

This whole thing really comes across as an interview process that is about soothing the interviewer more than it is about collecting empirical data that can be used (and iterated on) to qualify candidates. Be upbeat! Show that you've read the same Uncle Bob posts I have! Question me when it's important that something I said be questioned, but listen carefully and do what I tell you to in other cases!

Re:Notes from an Interviewer by angarg12 on Saturday February 24, 2024 @05:55PM (#39495902)
> Interviewing is a terrible way to screen candidates

so.... how do you suggest companies hire candidates? purely through referrals, without any further screening?

Re:Notes from an Interviewer by kasey_junk on Saturday February 24, 2024 @08:00PM (#39496631)
Thomas is a long time and outspoken proponent of work sample hiring. Here is his current companies process https://fly.io/docs/hiring/hiring/
Re:Notes from an Interviewer by dilyevsky on Saturday February 24, 2024 @08:14PM (#39496699)
This is not work sample - Oxide do work sample where they can take work you already completed. This is take-home test as described at least
Re:Notes from an Interviewer by tptacek on Saturday February 24, 2024 @08:24PM (#39496746)
Using OPM.gov's definition:

Work sample tests require applicants to perform tasks or work activities that mirror the tasks employees perform on the job.

You can call them "take-home tests" if you want, but that term is more general; lots of take-homes aren't work samples (they're not work samples if they're abstract coding puzzles that have nothing to do with the real work, for instance).

Re:Notes from an Interviewer by dilyevsky on Sunday February 25, 2024 @02:19PM (#39503833)
Ok sure, semantics aside, and not that i've seen Fly's take-home challenges, but how is it actually meaningfully different from zoom/in-person interviews in terms of being totally synthetic? Unless you're hiring for a junior role, it seems like isolated, pre-defined task is trivial part of the job...

I like your "work day" challenge though.

Re:Notes from an Interviewer by lubujackson on Saturday February 24, 2024 @08:33PM (#39496785)
Honestly, why not?

Obviously there needs to be SOME degree of vetting, but the way senior+ engineers are handled in the market is just absurd. The entire software engineering process is so closely tied to college classes with maybe a few years of professional work. All with the idea that "hiring the wrong person is terrible" but not considering that there may be thousands of developers that can effectively do the work.

If software engineering was handled like most other jobs, your work experience and references would be like 70% of what are considered. Instead, resumes serve as little more than initial screens at best, with all the weight given to leetcode results, pet questions and system design questions about how you'd build Uber in 10 minutes.

We act like its the 90s and literally everyone is new to the game. It's time to recognize the job has become a mature profession and we should treat it as such.