News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Everyone seems to forget why GNOME and GNOME 3 and Unity ... by lproven on Saturday February 24, 2024 @08:41AM (#39491401)
[Article author here]

> Red Hat didn't "create" GNOME

I didn't say they did.

> SuSe didn't "save" KDE

I never claimed they did.

(And it was SuSE, now just SUSE. When attempting to rebut, attention to detail is paramount.)

> Microsoft's legal threats were not what motivated the shift

[[Citation needed]]

> considering it came out 5 years later.

How long do you think this stuff takes?

> GNOME3 shifted because of design philosophies in a good chunk of the core developers

[[Citation needed]]

Or at least wanted. I'd like to know. I've met with the team, at their invitation and expense, and asked them personally, and I still didn't get a straight, coherent answer.

> a desire to have a more cohesive/user friendly experience a la Mac OS.

Well that failed then, didn't it?

Re:Everyone seems to forget why GNOME and GNOME 3 and Unity ... by bkor on Saturday February 24, 2024 @09:29AM (#39491710)
> > Microsoft's legal threats were not what motivated the shift > > [[Citation needed]]

You made that claim, it's on you to prove your claim. Instead, you claim something and pretend it is true unless someone provides proof about a claim that just isn't true.

> > GNOME3 shifted because of design philosophies in a good chunk of the core developers > > [[Citation needed]]

A release team member mentions that this is true. What more do you need? I was also a release team member for 10+ years. I've never heard of anything like what you claimed. I spoke to loads of people. Further, you're confusing GNOME 3 with gnome-shell. Also, GNOME 3 took ages to come out while you're pretending it was something quickly developed.

Lastly, GNOME classic. As shipped with RHEL 7. GNOME 3 with a more classical interface. Meaning, pretty close to GNOME 3.

Re:Everyone seems to forget why GNOME and GNOME 3 and Unity ... by fweimer on Saturday February 24, 2024 @11:36AM (#39492842)
Did you meant to write “pretty close to GNOME 2”?

Either way, it doesn't really matter. RHEL 6 was released in 2010 with a traditional menu for starting applications, long after the alleged cutoff date that, according to the article, should have made this impossible.

Re:Everyone seems to forget why GNOME and GNOME 3 and Unity ... by deaddodo on Saturday February 24, 2024 @09:08AM (#39491588)
> I didn't say they did.

You sure as hell heavily implied it then:

>> so Red Hat refused to bundle it or support it, and wrote its own environment instead.

Unless by "wrote its own environment" you mean "packaged GNOME instead of KDE".

> (And it was SuSE, now just SUSE. When attempting to rebut, attention to detail is paramount.)

Got me. Except I'm not the "journalist".

> How long do you think this stuff takes?

Considering development on it didn't begin until late 2008, about two years after the supposed "drastic need to shift"? 2.5-3yrs, give or take.

> Well that failed then, didn't it?

And so did the Zune. Yet it was still designed as an iPod-killer.

> [[Citation needed]]

You're making the claims in your half-researched/personally-biased article.

You cite them, ideally in the "article" itself.