Re:Jim Keller criticizes Nvidia's CUDA, x86
by gpderetta on Friday February 23, 2024 @09:49AM
(#39481205)
It seems I make this comment every 6 months or so, but... x86 uops are not at all RISC-style. They are very large (classic RISC uses 32bit encoding, uops are over 100 bits), variable size (classic RISC is fixed style, uops can use multiple slots to encode constants) and can encode load-op (classic RISC separates load and stores from operations).
There is also the fact that RISC-ness is a property of the ISA, so applying it to describe a microarchitecture doesn't make much sense.
There is also the fact that RISC-ness is a property of the ISA, so applying it to describe a microarchitecture doesn't make much sense.
edit: reference: https://www.quora.com/Why-are-RISC-processors-considered-fas... (sorry for the quora link)