News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GIMP 2.99.18: The last development preview before 3.0 by roelschroeven on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:43AM (#39468743)
I honestly don't see the problem with layers that have boundaries that are independent from the image boundaries. Maybe it's because I learned my way around Gimp before I used any other image editor, but it makes perfect sense to me.

When I crop, resize, move, ... a layer, its boundary is cropped, resized, moved, ... accordingly. What happens if you move a layer without boundaries, like in Photoshop? That's probably intuitive to people who are used to Photoshop, but not to me. What happens to contents that now fall out of the image boundary?

To explain layers in raster image editors to novices, they are often compared to transparent slides. Well, layers with boundaries are simply such slides. If I move a slide, the slide moves, including its boundaries; same with other operations.

Re:GIMP 2.99.18: The last development preview before 3.0 by walteweiss on Friday February 23, 2024 @07:02AM (#39479532)
Yeah, except it’s not slides. It’s a virtual canvas and there is no reason in the whole world for it to behave like it’s something physical, when it’s not. It makes zero sense, there shouldn’t be any checkbox in the first place. Just make it how it should be and never ask me. There’s enough checkboxes already. How can you develop a tool for designers if you never ask them first?