News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:XL: An Extensible Programming Language by samatman on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @04:40PM (#39459948)
> Are there any that come close to the usage of lisps with proper s-expressions?

If you consider Julia a Lisp, which I would argue you should, it may be the most widely-used Lisp currently. The only way you'll see an s-expression is is to call Meta.show_sexpr.

If you consider Dylan a Lisp, you should consider Julia a Lisp as well. If you don't consider Dylan a Lisp, I have to conclude that you consider the s-expressions to be part of the definition of a Lisp. Which isn't an unreasonable taxonomy, but isn't the one I use.

Re:XL: An Extensible Programming Language by diggan on Thursday February 22, 2024 @04:52AM (#39465114)
> If you consider Julia a Lisp

Maybe, but would you consider Julia a Lisp without parentheses, which was the context here? Because after looking at their documentation (https://docs.julialang.org/en/v1/manual/methods/ for example), it seems to have as many parens as any other lisp, just postfix notation rather than prefix notation, `f(Float32(2.0), 3.0)` vs `(f (Float32 2.0), 3.0)`.

Arguing about what makes or doesn't a lisp is a conversation I don't think will lead to any useful results, I feel like that's ongoing since the 60s or something. Out of my league :)

Re:XL: An Extensible Programming Language by samatman on Thursday February 22, 2024 @07:56AM (#39466394)
Given you said

> lisps with proper s-expressions

It's off-putting for you to fly in and pretend to be surprised that Julia uses parentheses in a way consistent with other languages which are syntactically Algolic. Apologies for expecting a serious conversation, didn't know who I was dealing with.

Re:XL: An Extensible Programming Language by diggan on Friday February 23, 2024 @10:51AM (#39482105)
The root context of the conversation you injected yourself into, was about lisps without parens. It's OK to misunderstand, but please don't blame me for your own misunderstanding.

Have a nice day!