It's just a simple display cable like HDMI. Not really a lot of cooperation needed.
> Also hand waving about "new codecs" doesn't hold any weight
Fair, but trying to watch a streaming service on a smart TV and being told "This device will not support X service after Y date" has happened.
https://www.tomsguide.com/news/these-old-devices-are-about-t...
https://www.reddit.com/r/Hulu/comments/xvaqqm/this_device_no...
https://www.amazonforum.com/s/question/0D54P00006zSxAMSA0/sm...
Again, that's a symptom of shitty manufacturer firmware, it's a burden on streaming services to support these devices because they are the ones that have to maintain software packages for hundreds of different TV models.
In contrast, Fire/GoogleTV OS are built on Android, so streaming networks don't need to support individual TV models, they just have to target supported versions of Fire/GoogleTV OS. Android has APIs to handle Smart TV functionality.
That's exactly my point.
I operate under the assumption that my TV will have shitty firmware. Always has been shitty, always will be shitty.
So rather than relegate the shittiness to a $1500+ device that will be very expensive to replace if/when the software becomes obsolete, I'd put the burden of shittiness to a $50 device that I don't mind upgrading as necessary.
Also hand waving about "new codecs" doesn't hold any weight. A Roku/Fire/Google TV is a Linux computer with hardware acceleration for all modern codecs. By the time AV1/VP9/H265 are being replaced in the 2030s, you're going to need a new TV anyway to support 8K and whatever other features are de rigueur then. Same goes for audio codecs and Wifi support.