For example, if GPU-based systems are the limiting factor they wouldn't have the edge. If the problem turns out to be in the human skills and background needed to develop an AGI they similarly wouldn't have the advantage.
Wouldn't there have to be a third scenario, where they walked down a path that doesn't pan out at all and requires a fundamental rethink effectively going back to square one?
Of course, a pretty good position doesn't guarantee winning, but GP didn't claim that.
But yeah, there are probably outcomes in which LLMs are a local maximum and ultimately dead end, and OpenAI will have a hard time holding on because the market turns out more competitive. And somebody might beat them to whatever the next important invention is. We'll see.
That is, you responded "We don't actually know this though. Assuming an AGI hasn't yet been developed, we don't know whether LLMs will actually get us there." Exactly, we don't know if this is true, in which case if it's false my second bullet point "LLMs turn out to be a 'local maximum' in the search for AGI." is the true statement.