>What prevents somebody from scanning it and reconstructing the position of the metal pieces?
You're talking about very, very small pieces of metal whose position/orientation is not deterministic when laying the glue and that information is combined with the tag itself to present some kind of challenge response.
If you use that, then the only way to move the NFC tag to another item would be to cut it out of the original item (including the original adhesive). But this attack also works against the technique in the article.
Regarding the orientation, I understand that it is nondeterministic in the original, but what prevents an attacker from copying it deterministically? Is it just that technology is not good enough to manipulate such small pieces of metal? How long will this limitation persist?
I hope to not be alive when technology progresses to that point!
Perhaps in future someone could develop an advanced combination of 3d printer and pick&place machines that could do it, but such future potential doesn't disqualify this tech from currently detecting counterfeiting of fancy shoes or something.
Coat a piece of glass with a thin layer of metal. Put a photoresist on top. Project the desired pattern onto it with UV light. Wash the unhardened photoresist away and etch the unnecessary metal.
Now you've got metal in exact the spots you'd like, of exactly the thickness you'd like. You can get the accuracy down to a few hundred micrometers for cheap today.
In the case of 3D arrangements, I think some substrate materials (and also some properties of the particles) would be very difficult to get using photolithography (or some kind of micro 3D printing).
Imagine e.g. the "multiple layers of cardboard cutouts" scenery in theater vs it actually being 3D.
Assuming that doing the process you describe is sufficient, what's the ballpark of what "for cheap" means for you if you needed to print 1000 different fake tags, assuming many layers of "the desired pattern" to print the metal flakes?
If you need perfectly sharp edges and high precision, sure. But I'm sure in this case that'd be unnecessary.
> Assuming that doing the process you describe is sufficient, what's the ballpark of what "for cheap" means for you if you needed to print 1000 different fake tags, assuming many layers of "the desired pattern" to print the metal flakes?
I described in another comment an additional way to quantize the layers to reduce the repetition steps, which would reduce costs further.
Regarding costs, you could fake a THzID chip for about 500€ per fake. Not cheap enough to do it for household items, but if you're faking designer bags, clothing, sneakers, or electronics, it'd be absolutely worth it.
NFC tag usually consists of two parts very tiny IC (small piece of silicon the size of sand grain) and antenna (a piece of metal foil in a fancy shape). You could make an NFC tag where attempting to remove it rips antenna, but that wouldn't destroy the IC. It's probably a matter of product price and quantities whether, counterfeiting it by reattaching the NFC chip to a new antenna is economically viable. As the process is not only possible it's performed at the NFC tag factory at very large quantities at very low cost. It might also be possible to repair parts of broken antenna assuming area around IC is undamaged.
So overall you get simplicity and cost of regular tamper resistance stickers, with better resistance against solvent and blade attacks, and security properties closer to what you get from secure NFC chip (except you can't perform more complicated cryptographic operations like signing arbitrary data).
> Is it just that technology is not good enough to manipulate such small pieces of metal? How long will this limitation persist?
I would expect that at any point in future, whatever the best controlled manufacturing technique invented are, it will be possible to create uncontrolled pattern at finer scale, or at least much cheaper. Unless we reach the point where maintaining stable state without deteriorating becomes a problem, or the quantity of data for storing and processing becomes impractical.
Perhaps a better solution is to create a small chip powered by electric induction. The chip would have an embedded private key and solve challenge-response queries issued by the scanning device.
I'm not sure how that compares in cost though.
Edit: it looks like these already exist and cost less than 10 cents a piece. They are called NFC tags.