News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GlobalFoundries wins $3.1B in CHIPS Act subsidies for NY,... by csomar on Monday February 19, 2024 @09:26AM (#39430050)
Because they do not fix the underlying causes; and also they create perverse incentives. Most companies are in the business of extracting money and will see this as such: an opportunity to extract money and the product is bureaucracy checkboxes. It would make more sense, in this personal view, to restrict sales to domestic production only and make sure the field is even for competitors to out-compete one another. This guarantee the dependency aspect at least (as you already restricted yourself!).

Another solution: Move the manufacturing to a near-shore and friendly country (ie: Mexico or Puerto Rico) and keep the design part in the US. But of course, that wouldn’t be as politically popular and wouldn’t create the extraction opportunity (which lots of companies will want to benefit from).

Re:GlobalFoundries wins $3.1B in CHIPS Act subsidies for NY,... by dragontamer on Monday February 19, 2024 @10:58AM (#39431169)
> to restrict sales to domestic production only

You think people will stop buying NVidia GPUs, AMD GPUs, PS5, XBox, Nintendo Switch, iPhone, Pixels, Samsung Galaxies, and a litany of major automotive parts from Microchip/STMicro/etc. etc.?

Because none of these are made in the USA. The only major chips made here are Flash/RAM by Crucial, CPUs by Intel, and some lower-tech (but still important) chips by TI. The vast majority of chips, well over 60% of the worldwide supply, is made by TSMC IIRC, and another huge chunk are made by other companies located in Taiwan.

--------------

Furthermore, Taiwan is a close ally who has extremely friendly relations with USA. Yes, there's a war-risk with China here, but Taiwan fairly competes with us. I don't think anyone has a single piece of anti-Taiwan hate inside of them.

Its not a protectionist thing. Its purely the "what if China attacks Taiwan" thing. Economically speaking, trade with Taiwan and USA is a good thing. Geopolitically, trade with Democracies is a good thing, and trade with a century+ old friendly nation is a good thing.

-------------

Taiwan can create this tech because they are smarter than us and outcompeted us on this subject. Its not "low tech", its extremely difficult chemistry, high-end PH.d stuff here.

Taiwan is basically the Vulkans from Star Trek. They're smaller, more technologically advanced, but weaker militarily. They're so obviously good allies that its unthinkable to do anything against them. We need a "just in case" plan if trade between our nations gets interrupted because chips are a strategic good, but... cutting them off would mean that they ally with someone else and that's even worse.

Re:GlobalFoundries wins $3.1B in CHIPS Act subsidies for NY,... by vel0city on Monday February 19, 2024 @11:58AM (#39431990)
> some lower-tech (but still important) chips by TI

TI makes plenty of pretty high-tech chips, just not necessarily bleeding edge digital logic processors. Their real high-tech stuff are analog devices, something far less sexy to people on HN but still incredibly crucial.

Re:GlobalFoundries wins $3.1B in CHIPS Act subsidies for NY,... by dragontamer on Monday February 19, 2024 @01:03PM (#39432738)
Analog is important for cutting another 20% off of MOSFET resistances or whatever, which means even more efficient electric engines or other electric components.

Yeah, important but not as much of a headline as 20% more GHz or FLOPs for some reason.

Re:GlobalFoundries wins $3.1B in CHIPS Act subsidies for NY,... by politician on Monday February 19, 2024 @12:06PM (#39432082)
It’s an accident of history and the hubris of Intel that they passed over an opportunity to buy the last generation machines from ASML leading to TSMC taking the advantage.

It’s not that they are intrinsically superior Vulkans as you’ve described.

It’s a temporary distortion caused by Intel trying to rest on their laurels and drip feed advancements.

Re:GlobalFoundries wins $3.1B in CHIPS Act subsidies for NY,... by dragontamer on Monday February 19, 2024 @12:16PM (#39432194)
Even *IF* Intel reaches parity with TSMC (which seems unlikely...), Intel doesn't have much experience with external customers (like Apple, Qualcomm, AMD, NVidia) like TSMC does.

Even if we magically wave a wand and give Intel next-generation lithography today, they still don't have the capabilities to take orders from customers and translate them to designs.

-----------

Its not Intel who needs to catch up to TSMC. Its a 3rd party fab like GloFo who needs to catch up for USA to recapture that market share.

I'm happy that GloFo is getting some scraps and investment from this CHIPS act, its the right move. But I have my doubts that we'll reach the technological level of TSMC / Taiwan any time soon. But whatever we get its still better than nothing.

Re:GlobalFoundries wins $3.1B in CHIPS Act subsidies for NY,... by politician on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @10:11AM (#39442211)
> Even if we magically...

ASML began to ship its first High-NA lithography tool to Intel late last year ,and the machine will be fully assembled in Oregon in the coming months. [1]

[1] https://www.anandtech.com/show/21264/asml-to-ship-multiple-h...

Re:GlobalFoundries wins $3.1B in CHIPS Act subsidies for NY,... by therealbilly on Monday February 19, 2024 @01:05PM (#39432767)
Not really. It’s because the government of Taiwan poured a lot of money into these chip companies. Which is the smart thing to do.
Re:GlobalFoundries wins $3.1B in CHIPS Act subsidies for NY,... by dragontamer on Monday February 19, 2024 @01:55PM (#39433297)
A lot of countries shoved tons of money into chips. In fact, a ton of countries have more money than Taiwan.

And yet, it's Taiwan who won. We gotta give them props for that, and we can also thank the gods that it was a close ally of the USA who got so good at it.

Re:GlobalFoundries wins $3.1B in CHIPS Act subsidies for NY,... by jacobsimon on Monday February 19, 2024 @09:46AM (#39430279)
This is a compelling perspective. But putting sales or import restrictions in place right now would be damaging in the short term both for the manufacturing partners and the US. They’ve already put some export restrictions in place (ie preventing nvidia from selling their most powerful chips to china).

In terms of nearshoring - that’s a good idea too but I think the workforce training would be even more difficult than it has been in the US and it would be less popular politically as you said. (Side note: PR is part of the US - maybe you meant Costa Rica)

Re:GlobalFoundries wins $3.1B in CHIPS Act subsidies for NY,... by coredog64 on Monday February 19, 2024 @01:17PM (#39432909)
Intel does (or used to do) wafer packaging in Costa Rica. On paper, CR is an attractive near shore location: Good amount of English speakers, time zone parity with the US, and not difficult to travel to.
Re:GlobalFoundries wins $3.1B in CHIPS Act subsidies for NY,... by edgyquant on Monday February 19, 2024 @09:40AM (#39430205)
If a certain former president is reelected he will likely continue to push for the type of tariffs that will incentivize domestic production over foreign imports. If that happens the chips act will have put us on the footing required for that ramp up to begin.
Re:GlobalFoundries wins $3.1B in CHIPS Act subsidies for NY,... by KoftaBob on Monday February 19, 2024 @10:07AM (#39430527)
> Move the manufacturing to a near-shore and friendly country (ie: Mexico or Puerto Rico)

Puerto Rico isn't a foreign country, it's a territory of the United States. Regardless of that, semiconductor fabrication is one of, if not THE most complex form of manufacturing.

It's not enough to simply build a fab in Mexico, the supply chain of materials and highly skilled labor that runs these fabs needs to exist there too. That's not to say that it can't exist somewhere like Mexico, but currently it doesn't and it would take longer to build up.

So while moving it to Mexico would remove the geopolitical risk problem, putting it there instead of the US would only give the advantage of cheaper labor but at the cost of taking much much longer to ramp up.

Re:GlobalFoundries wins $3.1B in CHIPS Act subsidies for NY,... by coredog64 on Monday February 19, 2024 @01:19PM (#39432937)
Not everything needs to be fabbed at 7 or 3 nm. Malaysia does well as a place where industrial nations can put mature manufacturing processes and get high quality outputs.