Re:A steep rise of Hacker News in Google rankings
by freedomben on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @09:14AM
(#39454035)
Yes absolutely. The source makes a massive difference! Every community site suffers from this problem whether it's HN, Reddit, or private torrent trackers. Blocking or making difficult new users is not the answer, that just filters out potentially great users. I don't know how you control for source though without turning it into "you have to know somebody" which tends to isolate people who don't know people IRL.
I agree it probably doesn't make sense to try to block growth sources though. Just considering the perspective "it's not effective to try to play whack a mole anyways" already seems enough evidence of that alone.
All this reminds me though I've been using the site too much lately and my interaction quality has gone down. Time for another short break :). Anyways