> Small platforms have way less fraud because they are way less valuable to exploit, in general.
Yes.
> The big platforms actually are radically more competent at anti-fraud / anti-spam / etc, but the scope of their operations make them such juicy targets that there is a lot of it anyways.
If their business model (scale above everything) results in shitty customer experience I don't really care how competent they are. They are fighting the problem they created themselves: a platform too valuable for scammers.
It's a tradeoff. If your customer service is good such that more people shop there, there will be more fraud attempts overall.
It's not that a platform is too valuable for scammers, it's that a platforms is valuable at all. All platform value is value for scammers, and the most useful platform will also have the most scammers on it
It's not true. Scale bring synergy and reduces costs. But it's a two-way road which works for scams too: scamming one big platform and fighting one anti-fraud system is ten times more cost-efficient than adjusting to ten smaller ones.
> The big platforms actually are radically more competent at anti-fraud / anti-spam / etc
No, they're not. They are purposely incompetent at those things, because it's part of their business model. They cannot implement actual competence (which would mean providing sufficient actual human support to deal with the volume of mistakes that their automated algorithms make), not because it would cost too much (the article quite correctly points out that their huge profits provide plenty of cash to pay for human moderation), but because it would reduce their value to their actual customers, who are not their users.
Perhaps I can squint and see how an email platform like Gmail could be read as a protection racket, but I don't see it in other platforms.
It doesn't; that's not the point. The point is, as I said, that the big platforms make money by selling access to as large a pool of users as possible, and that requires them to not crack down on spammers and fraudsters--because at their scale, it is impossible for them to reliably distinguish the spammers and fraudsters from the rest of their users. So they can't crack down on spammers and fraudsters without also reducing the size of their user pool and thereby killing their business model.
The article explicitly talks about this:
Either you have to back off and only ban users in cases where you're extremely confident, or you ban all your users after not too long and, as companies like to handle support, appealing means that you'll get a response saying that "your case was carefully reviewed and we have determined that you've violated our policies. This is final", even for cases where any sort of cursory review would cause a reversal of the ban, like when you ban a user for impersonating themselves. And then at FB's scale, it's even worse and you'll ban all of your users even more quickly, so then you back off and we end up with things like 100k minors a day being exposed to "photos of adult genitalia or other sexually abusive content".
Spam and fraud still generates "engagement" (whether the bad content itself or the people getting outraged by it) which contributes to the numbers they use to attract & bill advertisers.
The modus operandi of these platforms when it comes to moderation is to quickly take down whatever will get them in trouble fast with the law (DMCA takedowns, CSAM), or what will provide ammunition for attack pieces in the media (pornography, sometimes drug- or weapon-related content). But anything else is fair game to stay and earn "engagement" even in the face of user-submitted reports.
In the unlikely event that this "anything else" does get reported on in some big media, then it'll be taken down and they'll issue an apology and how they will do better in the future, and everyone seems to buy it no matter how many times they've done this.
Irrespective of whether or not a platform is small or large, can they make their customer whole 100% of the time? Why or why not?
Just to work one (real) example:
1. Buy expensive face cream from Amazon
2. Take out the expensive stuff and replace it with junk
3. Complain to Amazon that you got junk and need a refund.
The challenge here becomes obvious. Even in claims where the customers was allegedly a victim, some portion of those customers are fraudsters. So any policy that results in a large, profitable company will likely result in something less than 100% of legitimate fraud cases from being satisfactorily resolved.
In the case of the small business, they are very unlikely to be targeted by industrial scale fraud and will probably just be able to solve this with personal relationships and human judgment.
That said, the price you pay the small operator is very likely to be meaningfully higher than the price of the scaled operator.
If you care more about having near 100% probability of having fraud/abuse cases addressed than you care about benefiting from the economies of scale, then yeah, go with the small operator.
In things like communities, my general sense is that there is almost no beneficial economies of scale. So I like to hang out in smaller places. But in things like information retrieval (ie. Google), the benefits are usually worth it for me to use that.
The question of the company itself being defrauded by some number of customers and having to defend against that as it becomes increasing larger is definitely valid and difficult to tackle at scale. However, I think it is a totally separate one. I do not think it is a necessity for the company to compromise the ability to make any one dissatisfied customer whole just because they are being targeted by a whole lot of fraudsters all at once. The company might have to increased their costs on their products to pay for things like additional training, tamper-evident packaging, improving supply chain management, and so on.
The correct amount of fraud the platforms tolerate against themselves is definitely >0%, and it's for the reason you're identifying.
It seems that you're assuming it's obvious to identify good-faith consumers and do right by them. In some cases that's true. If you're a loyal, repeat customer of Amazon's they will basically just do whatever you ask them (within reason). But there are many cases where the act of discriminating between fraudster and Good Samaritan is in fact the whole of the challenge.
Indeed, one of the most common exploits is to hack the account of good customers and abuse merchants that way.
There's a dark, dark underbelly of crime out there. And the cost of that is borne by all of us in occasionally-less-than-good customer experiences.
They do make their customers (i.e., the companies who pay them for access to their users) whole. But their users (at least the vast majority of them) are not their customers; they don't pay for the service. (It's true, as the article points out, that even paid support at the big platforms is very poor, but that's because the money involved is still not even rounding error compared to the astronomical profits being made from selling access to their users.)
They can't make their users whole, or even a significant fraction of them, without breaking their business model. That's why they don't do it.
There is a fair (but tolerable) amount of click-fraud, etc that you basically factor as a cost of doing busines.
I'm quite skeptical of the ad model myself, but I'm relatively sure that "you are not the customer" is not altogether the most salient argument to make in this thread.
"Meaningful amounts" to most ad customers is not the same as "meaningful amounts" to the platforms.
In my first read, I took that to mean from a process and inputs viewpoint.
But reading it again, I suppose the author could be taking a more consequentialist point of view. They are at least as good (or much better), largely because they don't have to do much.
I suppose that's fair, but also a lot of words in the OP to state a truism :-)
The author addresses this point in one of the appendices:
>> A standard extension of this idea that I frequently hear is that big companies actually do have the best anti-spam and anti-fraud, but they're also subject to the most sophisticated attacks. I've seen this used as a justification for why big companies seem to have worst anti-spam and anti-fraud than a forum like HN. While it's likely true that big companies are subject to the most sophisticated attacks, if this whole idea held and it were the case that their systems were really good, it would be harder, in absolute terms, to spam or scam people on reddit and Facebook than on HN, but that's not the case at all.
This response makes intuitive sense. If the big companies are indeed more effectively competent at anti-abuse/anti-fraud measures, then the fraud that does slip through should be more subtle and less obvious, particularly over a prolonged period.
Those who work anti-fraud for platforms know that there is something like a market for fraud. There is a market clearing quantity of fraud that will be present on any platform, dictated by the gains from learning to execute the exploit, the effort necessary to do so, and the number of times one might be able to do it.
Small platforms have way less fraud because they are way less valuable to exploit, in general. And that's caused by _the very fact that they are small_.
The big platforms actually are radically more competent at anti-fraud / anti-spam / etc, but the scope of their operations make them such juicy targets that there is a lot of it anyways.
It the entire world of fraudsters against Amazon, or Google, or Facebook. That's a highly unequal battle and it's surprising how well the platforms fare, all things considered.