Re:Everything Is a Linear Model
by bongodongobob on Sunday February 18, 2024 @07:48PM
(#39425110)
Can you give some examples of linear and non-linear materials?
Re:Everything Is a Linear Model
by pistachiopro on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:07PM
(#39425195)
Practically all materials behave nonlinearly when stretched or compressed a visible amount. For certain structural applications, though, if that happens we've already failed. Linear models work really well for designing big concrete structures and certain metal structures. Sometimes we try to apply linear models to other things, but that's always kind of fishy.
Re:Everything Is a Linear Model
by olivierduval on Monday February 19, 2024 @02:49AM
(#39427135)
It's funny: I had the EXACT SAME PROBLEM !!!! Like "how is it science when a prof says: "this equation is too complicated too solve so let's erase these third and forth derivatives and pretend that it's the same - even if it's not - because that's all that we can do"
So I left the "physics" courses and went the "math" courses... only to learn 3 years later how to prove that this kind of approximation is mathematically sound indeed :-D
Re:Everything Is a Linear Model
by AstralStorm on Monday February 19, 2024 @03:23AM
(#39427301)
Should have taken one more course about chaos theory which is the special case when this approach fails.
At the time I was mad at engineers for being non-scientific, but after a few years I understood the deep wisdom in that. Nonlinear materials exist, and materials we use have nonlinear ranges. We just don't build things from those, because the math is too unwieldy. (except in very very specific edge cases where we spend a lot of money building a very limited thing)