Oh wait, they don't. Just ditch it and let anyone move money around with no controls. I'm sure that would work out fine.
It did, for thousands of years. The only thing that's new is the ability to track every penny and person from cradle to grave and the incessant and ever-growing desire for those in power to control those who aren't.
Not to mention that if the gold is banked then it probably didn't need transport because it was being transported too and from a bank.
no tax, no control (look at The Emirates).
However, as it gets easier and easier to accrue wealth on behalf of others, the taxing schemes are probably needed, and so is the control.
and for thousands of years the rich did pretty much what they wanted, and the rest of us lived barely above subsistence level.. fair taxation is one of the building blocks of modern society
That's like saying going without vaccinations, clean water, or adequate medical care "worked out fine" for thousands of years.
Sure, the human race survived. Many individuals even thrived. But I don't think it's really disputable that life with them is massively better than life was before we had them (or, in fact, than life is now for the far too many who still lack them in a reliable way).
because they could avoid paying their taxes?
They're both violations of people's privacy.
>There's no evidence provided for these numbers
And KYC proponents provide no empirical evidence that KYC has actually led to a measurable reduction in organised crime. The onus should be on them to demonstrate why it's effective enough to justify the violation of citizens' privacy that it entails.
This is meaningless.
You get to weird places if you try to wrap an entire worldview around privacy the way people do expression or self-determination, because privacy does not have that standing.
Having worked in an industry with strict kyc requirements and worked for a well known payment processor, if they were only catching 1% then some truly absurd amount of business is fraudulent.
https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/Studies/Il...
> Globally, it appears that much less than 1% (probably around 0.2%) of the proceeds of crime laundered via the financial system are seized and frozen.
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/25741292.2020.1...
> the confiscation rate might be 0.07 percent. In other words, despite ubiquitous money laundering controls, criminals retain up to 99.93 percent of criminal proceeds.
and KYC isn't only for money laundering, it's also for tax fraud
You may as well say, "KYC might deter a large fraction - let's say about 99% of these malefactors"
There's no evidence provided for these numbers. It's one thing to make an assumption which is counter to your argument - "Even if 99% of criminals are deterred, it creates an unconscionable burden upon those whose identities are stolen" or etc.
It's quite another just to assume your own argument. Let's assume cops prevent 99% of crime - it's worth their brutality or whatever. Let's assume cops prevent 1% of crime - we would be better off with 1% more crime and no cops or whatever.
It's absolutely pointless.
The article goes on to immediately compare KYC with widespread facial recognition. Why are these equivalent?
They could at least try to engage with arguments for KYC - that large financial institutions should not be making life easier for criminals. Historically, a bank obviously knew their customers - they had to open the accounts in person, talk with the bank manager, etc.