News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Guix on the Framework 13 AMD by goosedragons on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:26AM (#39396011)
The other big thing is that being a FSF project they are much more committed to free software than Nix. It's harder to get stuff like Chrome, Steam, Nvidia drivers etc. Not impossible but you're definitely swimming against the current in trying.
Re:Guix on the Framework 13 AMD by kdtsh on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:32AM (#39396090)
Important to note that it’s not hard or swimming against the current - you just use the nonguix channel, which has all of those things and is a perfectly acceptable use of the system (it’s what channels are for) - but it’s not in the default installation.
Re:Guix on the Framework 13 AMD by ducktective on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:57AM (#39396342)
>you just use the nonguix channel

Opened up https://gitlab.com/nonguix/nonguix. Literally the second sentence in the project information section, top of the page:

"Please do NOT promote or refer to this repository on any official Guix communication channels."

Weird thing to say something like this there. Too ideological for someone who wants to get stuff done.

Re:Guix on the Framework 13 AMD by bheadmaster on Friday February 16, 2024 @08:25AM (#39396674)
It makes sense to me.

They don't want to compromize their mission - which is to provide a fully-free operating system. But they recognize that, at the current moment, non-free software is required for many users. So they maintain an unofficial repository for non-free software, and avoid endorsing or promoting it on the official channels.

> Too ideological for someone who wants to get stuff done.

The maintainers of Nonguix are mostly the same people working on Guix, so you can expect the same amount of ideology :)

Re:Guix on the Framework 13 AMD by davexunit on Friday February 16, 2024 @08:14AM (#39396530)
I agree this policy should change but I and many others get stuff done just fine.
Re:Guix on the Framework 13 AMD by Modified3019 on Friday February 16, 2024 @04:29PM (#39403226)
This is what ultimately bounced me away, along with seeing some negative interactions others had. Sure I might not end up with problems, but I’m going to choose to believe them when they tell me the official communication channels will be hostile to me if I do have problems that need the unclean fixes.

Which is a shame, because I think there are some technical things which guix does better, but I find it’s more important to not have to worry about saying the wrong things in the wrong places when troubleshooting basic issues like what I get with the nix community.

Re:Guix on the Framework 13 AMD by rekado on Friday February 16, 2024 @05:13PM (#39403651)
That's an unfortunate take. "Unclean" is your choice of words, not ours. There is no hostility to people who use proprietary software, nor is any kind of judgement of other people's computing purposes and habits warranted.

Personally, I avoid proprietary software where I can, but I've found myself in many situations where I'm made to use it. But that's really the point: the free software movement's goal is to create a world in which people are no longer compelled or coerced or forced into being mistreated by proprietary software. You don't need to subscribe to these values, of course, but it is unfortunate if you experience this goal as a personal judgment. Keep in mind that one of the four software freedoms is the freedom to use software for any purpose you want --- judgement of users would be a completely misdirected emotion.

Having said that, the Guix project's communication channels simply aren't for proprietary software. The Nonguix communication channels are. The HPC channels are. You will likely get redirected to those communication channels if you ask about proprietary software on Guix project channels.

Re:Guix on the Framework 13 AMD by kdtsh on Friday February 16, 2024 @06:48PM (#39404596)
I wouldn’t say it’s too ideological for someone who wants to get stuff done. To get stuff done with Guix, you just go do it and it won’t get in your way - the project channel and the nonguix channel won’t interfere with each other, they’re just different channels.

Directions for using Guix in practice (i.e. with some non-free software) could definitely be easier to find, especially if you start green and don’t know what you’re meant to be looking for. But the system won’t get in your way.

Re:Guix on the Framework 13 AMD by davexunit on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:46AM (#39396219)
Yeah I second this. I use the nonguix channel for my laptop. Very well supported and easy to use.
Re:Guix on the Framework 13 AMD by Filligree on Friday February 16, 2024 @11:51AM (#39399558)
It's (deliberately) difficult to discover. I tried GuixSD once, and bounced off it because of the apparent lack of support for my hardware, CUDA, Pytorch et al, which isn't an uncommon story apparently.

Now, seemingly there are channels that would deal with this. But when I asked through the official channels, I was told not to do that -- that is, "don't use nvidia dummy", which really isn't an option. I was never pointed to the non-free channel.

Re:Guix on the Framework 13 AMD by kdtsh on Friday February 16, 2024 @06:50PM (#39404612)
I agree with that - directions for how to use Guix in practice, i.e. for someone who isn’t a GNU warrior using 15 year old hardware because you don’t need non-free blobs, need to be easier to come across.
Re:Guix on the Framework 13 AMD by pasc1878 on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:28AM (#39396046)
Another big thing is Guix only works on GNU/Linux and not on macOS and other Unixes like FreeBSD which Nix does run on.