News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:BitTorrent Everything? by TomAnthony on Sunday May 06, 2012 @06:18PM (#3936535)
I imagine there are many technical reasons why this is a bad idea. A few from the top of my head:

• Very few sites could allow their database to be distributed.

• Pages could be altered by nodes in the network for nefarious reasons.

• Anything with a session would probably be very hard work.

Shame really, as it'd make it harder of ISPs to shape traffic.

Re:BitTorrent Everything? by engxover on Sunday May 06, 2012 @06:46PM (#3936643)
I'll admit I wasn't thinking of databases when I posed the question, and you're absolutely right about sessions. Anything with a log-in would be quite difficult, and out of my league to even imagine.

As for alteration of pages, what about "hashes"? Isn't the point of a hashsum to make sure the torrent is correct? My thoughts of how this process would work are:

1. You browse the internet as usual, except for a browser add-on that would check links to see if they were available in torrent form.

2. As you click on a link, your browser either loads the webpage in torrent form, or saves the site in torrent form for seeding.

3. More users = more sites in torrent form = faster browsing speeds.

Again, wouldn't work with log-in sites, but for something static like Wikipedia, wouldn't this be incredibly helpful for cutting costs, reducing server load, etc? And whenever a page is updated, Wikipedia simply uploads the new version with it's new hashtag for browser checks.

I hope that clarifies my thinking. So is this a good idea at all? Or still fraught with downsides?

Re:BitTorrent Everything? by brianshaler on Sunday May 06, 2012 @06:46PM (#3936642)
• Pages could be altered by nodes in the network for nefarious reasons.

Not if you use a BitTorrent model. You'd get checksums from a known source and discard any chunks you receive from nodes that don't match the expected checksum. Not impossible to spoof/alter, but exceedingly unlikely.

Re:BitTorrent Everything? by Hrundi on Sunday May 06, 2012 @09:02PM (#3937074)
Similar to our trust on the 13 root servers then.

I guess this all depends on who to trust.