Re:So You Think You Know Git – Git Tips and Tricks by Scott ...
by Shacklz on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @04:48PM
(#39363301)
> But its design is far, very far from the most important software design principle (KISS)
My suggestion was more to look at the underlying data-model, which really isn't that much harder to grasp than what your average undergrad datastructure course teaches. Git really does solve a rather complex problem in a quite elegant way - it just so happens that the packaging around it (the cli) is indeed a bit more controversial.
I can only speak for myself but once I started to look at git less like "a tool" and rather from a perspective of datastructure/algorithms etc. (which are inherently agnostic to how they're implemented), it started to make sense to me rather quick (a matter of hours actually, which is nothing compared to the countless of hours I've already wasted trying to find the right cheat-sheet-incantation before).
But then there is Mercurial, used it decade and a half ago and it contained literally everything good about distributed model I could ever wish for, with maybe 50% of Git's complexity. Yet cargo-culting gonna cargo-cult, if Linus uses it so must we since we are not subpar and the rest be damned.
Yes sure its the tool to stay, and eventually can be learned well. But its design is far, very far from the most important software design principle (KISS).