Re:Facebook Stops You From Posting ‘Irrelevant Or Inappropri...
by ojbyrne on Sunday May 06, 2012 @01:23PM
(#3935632)
So what if you post not one "LOL" but thousands or millions of "LOL"s? Furthermore, what if the whole purpose of you posting millions of "LOL"s was to defeat spam filters. Would it be spam then?
Re:Facebook Stops You From Posting ‘Irrelevant Or Inappropri...
by heyitsnick on Sunday May 06, 2012 @01:37PM
(#3935672)
Yes ban accounts that are clearly abusing comments with thousands or millions of "LOL".
No need to detect on individual comments if something is deemed "appropriate" or not.
Spam is broadly defined as unsolicited bulk advertising. An example spam comment would be "LOL! Also check out this great pharmaceutical company: xxx".
The latter is certainly something that should be filtered out, if it's irrelevant advertising that marketers are using to peddle their crap. It's mostly unsubjective and uncontextual and its appropriate for filters to automatically detect.
But filtering out the former is a form of censorship that is often best left to humans (like downvotes to bury bad comments). I don't think this should be the job of the comments system to determine what is considered "appropriate" or "beneficial to the discussion."
A "LOL" or ASCII art image or "no u" or any other meme can be anything from a well-timed ironic offhand jab, an appropriate affirmation or response, to totally irrelevant and inappropriate noise. It depends on topic, context, parent, and existing noise in the thread and is inherently objective.