No, if I found out that the sculpture was 3d printed instead of sculpted by hand I wouldn't be as impressed. The value for me is derived both from the difficulty and the result. The result itself is impressive — if I saw a 17 foot tall statue towering over me I would be a bit impressed regardless of the methods used to produce it, but I also find it impressive imagining a man operating under the constraints of his tools, and the skill those constraints require.
> https://youtu.be/WPL7D0Ha1kQ
It's a cool thought experiment to imagine the Dutch Masters using a camera lucida to trace their paintings. If Vermeer traced his paintings I would indeed be less impressed with his work. I feel like we're going in circles restating the same points over and over again.
> It was a scandal because many use costly signals (ability to play sports / games or create or acquire stuff like “art”) to rank each other in hierarchies. What matters is the ranking. If the result mattered, anything that improves the result would be welcome, not rejected as “cheating”.
In the example we're discussing what is the meaningful "result" of a game of chess? It's literally a board game where you move small objects across a tiled surface for entertainment. To me you sound like someone saying "if people cared about the result of a foot race, they would let the runners drive cars". You've gone so far down the rabbit hole of defending AI that you're trying to undermine the idea of sports and games.
> Do you not question whether the enormous amount of time and effort various historical works cost was well spent? What if that time and effort was instead spent researching something useful?
How much time and effort have you spent trying to persuade me that art, sports, and games are frivolous? Maybe your time would be better spent researching something useful rather than writing these comments.
> Are science research / publications such an activity? For some, yes. For others, no. How do you see it?
I must have said this at least 5 or 6 times at this point, but I don't mind someone using AI to help them write a scientific paper. I just want creators who don't use AI to be credited for their work.
> If instead the author was told it was the work of a genius and not hers that may actually be accepted as a compliment -- if she maintains that high quality in the future what else can that be but an honest compliment on the quality of her work?
It could be considered a way of dismissing someone's effort and talent. If for example reviewers only questioned women about whether or not they were plagiarizing geniuses, I don't imagine they would find that very flattering.
> Many see a sharp difference between “human” and “machine” yet the medicine we rely on assumes we are machines. I think many know this but do not realize the implications. To think about it can be uncomfortable.
The idea that you can use the English word "machine" to describe a human being is not the deep philosophical insight that you perceive it to be. There's nothing uncomfortable about it, because you're just playing a language game. A doctor would have no problem treating your illness without referencing the word "machine". This would maybe be an uncomfortable truth to an undergrad taking their first philosophy course.
> Your attitude I suspect is because you do not see you already are upgraded from what you would be otherwise. Your mind has been upgraded with language and is full of useful concepts and techniques that are not your own.
I'm fully aware of the fact that human beings are already being upgraded. I specifically gave you the example of cochlear implants in my previous comment to indicate my awareness, which are a much more concrete example than your abstract "language, concepts, and techniques" example. I know these concepts feel revolutionary to you, but they're not to me.
We've gone astray here but the topic of human upgrades came up because I asked you a simple question: if you only value the results of a process, rather than the human who derived the result, then what happens when humans are no longer required to produce any result? Do you propose that the only way we can stay relevant in such a society is to upload our minds to AWS where hardware can make us more intelligent than our wetware? I don't know about you, but I don't plan on becoming a brain in a vat in some datacenter, and I definitely don't plan on becoming a file on someone's Digital Ocean droplet. We might just have different preferences.
“Labor Theory of Value” vs “Marginal Utility Theory of Value”: you are familiar with these yet you still hold that view? The output of a less efficient process to create something comparable is more valuable _because_ a less efficient process was used?
> If Vermeer traced his paintings I would indeed be less impressed with his work.
The excellent https://youtu.be/WPL7D0Ha1kQ documentary presents evidence that he did use tracing. In contrast to you that evidence made me more impressed with Verneer’s work.
> In the example we're discussing what is the meaningful "result" of a game of chess?
I answered that. Above I said “many use costly signals (ability to play sports / games or create or acquire stuff like “art”) to rank each other in hierarchies”.
GPT4 explains: ”From an evolutionary standpoint, games and sports can be seen as extensions of primal competitions for resources, mates, and status. Competing and displaying skills in a controlled environment can serve as a non-lethal way to establish dominance and hierarchy within a group. This is similar to how animals engage in play-fighting or displays of strength to determine pecking orders without resorting to serious conflict.”
What evolutionary purpose do you think games and sports serve if not the purpose above? It seems to me you like the “labor theory of value” because for you creating things is like a sport or game where ranking is important and difficulty of the task matters and innovation is “cheating” for the purpose of ranking.
> How much time and effort have you spent trying to persuade me that art, sports, and games are frivolous? Maybe your time would be better spent researching something useful rather than writing these comments.
Our chat is like a dialogue I have with myself (or with chatGPT) when I debate views to make up my mind about them: A joint search for truth. When a smart person (as you obviously are) changes my views on an important topic I am obviously better for it. And even if you do not change my mind, the thinking exercise is valuable. Thank you!
> I just want creators who don't use AI to be credited for their work.
Why would creators who do not use AI not get credit for their work? When you say the above you mean they should get extra credit? And would you give them even more extra credit when they did all their research without the help of any machines? Why does it matter if machines helped? Why not judge the research publication on its own merits? You want extra credits to handicap those using better tools because research is a game in which the difficulty must be maintained otherwise it is “cheating”?
> The idea that you can use the English word "machine" to describe a human being is not the deep philosophical insight that you perceive it to be. There's nothing uncomfortable about it, because you're just playing a language game. A doctor would have no problem treating your illness without referencing the word "machine". This would maybe be an uncomfortable truth to an undergrad taking their first philosophy course.
Your mind perhaps rejects the idea that why you think I am playing a language game using a metaphor when I am not using a metaphor. For you there is nothing uncomfortable accepting that living things are machines? I think you have not thought about the consequences of accepting this view: https://chat.openai.com/share/2fdd8863-6a3b-4a09-9d9c-b2f196...
> if you only value the results of a process, rather than the human who derived the result, then what happens when humans are no longer required to produce any result?
Our lives will likely change much like our lives of wandering around from place to place hunting gathering changed and then lives of subsistence farming changed, etc. If you accept the view that living things are machines (not as a metaphor but in reality) the concept of computational universality may give you a clue about our likely future. GPT4 explains: https://chat.openai.com/share/4dd5e6b3-6136-408a-a05a-10261d...
> I don't know about you, but I don't plan on becoming a brain in a vat in some datacenter, and I definitely don't plan on becoming a file on someone's Digital Ocean droplet. We might just have different preferences.
Assuming it is possible: How do you feel about having observations of what you say and write and do being used to create a model that can predict these things about you with such accuracy that those that know you can not tell the difference? Will that model in a “computational sense” not be you? Say, if given a matching body, that model can replace you such that those that know you cannot tell the difference. Will that also not be you? If you accept the reality that you are a machine, why will that not also be you? Because you are the atoms that make you you?
This is one of those comments that appears quite witty at first glance, but crumbles upon examination. First of all, I didn't say I value meticulously crafted art such as Michelangelo's statue of David because a _less efficient_ process was used to create it. I said I value it because of the _skill_ involved in creating it. As a human being, I naturally admire other skilled human beings. The reason why Michelangelo had to cultivate such a skill is obviously because of the state of technology during his lifetime, but that's completely beside the point. I'll take your comment in good faith and assume you truly misunderstood.
Second, macroeconomic theory is best left in my opinion to goods and services that are fungible. So for example, you could use macroeconomic theory to explain the price of a commodity such as pure gold, because any pound of gold is just as valuable as any other pound of pure gold. Art is inherently non-fungible though. Not only are two similar pieces of art not equal in value, but two identical pieces of art are not identical in value (e.g. a forgery or replica isn't as valuable as the original). Even the crypto bros understand the difference between fungible and non fungible tokens. You could argue about why it is that humans value the non-tangible aspects of art, but it's a key component of our psyche. Valuing these aspects doesn't make you a Marxist, or an adherent to the Labor Theory of Value. Some of the most hardcore marginal utilitarians would find value in the original Declaration of Independence as opposed to a forgery for example.
> The excellent https://youtu.be/WPL7D0Ha1kQ documentary presents evidence that he did use tracing. In contrast to you that evidence made me more impressed with Verneer’s work.
I would be more impressed by the person who supposedly invented the camera lucida almost two hundred years before any written or physical evidence of it appeared.
> I answered that.
No you provided an answer to the wrong question. You said in an earlier comment "If the result mattered, anything that improves the result would be welcome, not rejected as “cheating”." In this case the result being the outcome of a game of chess. What you are describing in your most recent comment is the motivation that drives people to sit at the chess board in the first place, which is a completely orthogonal topic.
What I'm trying to get you to explain is how AI could possibly "innovate" once the competitors are sitting at the board. This is why I said you sound to me like someone suggesting that it would be "innovative" to allow cars in a foot race. Follow your own logic via reductio ad absurdum and see where it leads you. Forget AI, if we wanted to "innovate" in competitive games we'd allow adults to compete in children's sporting competitions, surely that would "improve the result"? I can't believe I'm explaining the concept of games to a fellow human being. Games are not primarily a science problem to be solved (or "innovated" upon) by a computer, they're a form of leisure. I've never had to ask this before, but are you a human being?
Also, what about games that have been completely solved by computers such as checkers? We literally know what a perfect game of checkers looks like. If we used your method of "innovation" every game of checkers would be identical, because each participant would simply play the predetermined perfect game as calculated by a computer. When computers inevitably solve chess do you propose that we discontinue the game altogether since there's no longer any innovation left to be had?
> It seems to me you like the “labor theory of value”
You're vastly over-applying this principle. When you discover a new theory it's tempting to apply it to everything. The profession of economics is not in the business of deciding whether or not AI should be allowed in board games.
Thank you for the compliment. It's a nice change of pace here on HN where everyone is convinced of their own intellectual superiority.
> Why would creators who do not use AI not get credit for their work? When you say the above you mean they should get extra credit? And would you give them even more extra credit when they did all their research without the help of any machines? Why does it matter if machines helped? Why not judge the research publication on its own merits? You want extra credits to handicap those using better tools because research is a game in which the difficulty must be maintained otherwise it is “cheating”?
Two things:
First, let's not conflate two separate issues here. Something can be a truly abysmal piece of work and I can still credit the creator of it. We often use the word blame to describe credit given in the negative sense, but it's the exact same concept. See for instance git blame: https://git-scm.com/docs/git-blame. I think you internally believe this to a certain extent as well, which is why you consistently cite ChatGPT whenever you use it (despite supposedly believing it's no more worthy of credit than a font or a spellchecker).
Second, I've said this several times at this point but I don't have a problem with a researcher using AI, and I don't think they should be "handicapped" for using it. The criteria a scientific journal uses to evaluate a paper need not be the same one that a layman uses to evaluate it. I'm fine with scientific journals accepting papers from authors who use AI if it advances the state of science, and I'm ok with them not even being aware of the tools used to produce a given paper to avoid bias during the review process, but if I read a truly well written paper as a layman I should be able to congratulate the person who wrote the prose after it's published, and that requires being able to establish provenance. Do you really have a problem with someone saying "I wrote this paper, not ChatGPT"? Does that really offend you, or somehow hinder science?
> Your mind perhaps rejects the idea that why you think I am playing a language game using a metaphor when I am not using a metaphor. For you there is nothing uncomfortable accepting that living things are machines? I think you have not thought about the consequences of accepting this view: https://chat.openai.com/share/2fdd8863-6a3b-4a09-9d9c-b2f196...
I never said you're using a metaphor. I've already clarified that when I use the word machine I'm using it in the commonly accepted colloquial sense of the term (i.e. non-biological machine). Rather than discuss the actual issue at hand (what happens to humans in a world where machines render us obsolete), you would instead prefer to broaden the term machine itself so that it encompasses literally anything. If you want to truly be this pedantic anything can be considered a machine. Earth is just the machine that transports us around the sun every 365 days. The Moon is the machine that regulates our tides. The universe itself could be conceptualized as the machine made up of galaxy clusters. Do you see how unproductive it is to play games with semantics? For someone who supposedly doesn't care about communication, and is purely interested in science, you spend a lot of time quibbling over semantics.
> Our lives will likely change much like our lives of wandering around from place to place hunting gathering changed and then lives of subsistence farming changed, etc. If you accept the view that living things are machines (not as a metaphor but in reality) the concept of computational universality may give you a clue about our likely future. GPT4 explains: https://chat.openai.com/share/4dd5e6b3-6136-408a-a05a-10261d...
All of your GPT links lead to 404 errors for me, so there's not much for me to respond to here. This is the problem with outsourcing your thinking to OpenAI. Your external "brain" is owned and operated by a private company, and can be thwarted by HTTP errors.
> Assuming it is possible: How do you feel about having observations of what you say and write and do being used to create a model that can predict these things about you with such accuracy that those that know you can not tell the difference? Will that model in a “computational sense” not be you? Say, if given a matching body, that model can replace you such that those that know you cannot tell the difference. Will that also not be you? If you accept the reality that you are a machine, why will that not also be you? Because you are the atoms that make you you?
There's a metaphysical argument to be made here about whether or not destroying your physical body and recreating yourself as a file on a computer constitutes death, but I have more pressing practical problems.
I'll preface this by saying that I normally don't categorically dismiss opinions, but I truly believe that people who advocate in favor of mind uploading haven't fully thought through the implications. Imagine a world in which a data breach doesn't just mean your personal information is being leaked, but your literal brain is being leaked to the public. Computers could speed up or slow down your subjective perception of time, so a hacker could duplicate your brain, and subject your digital clone to an eternity of existence inside a digital nightmare. In a mind uploading scenario, billions of people could be erased by simply reformatting a hard drive. The delete key becomes more troublesome than an ICBM in this situation. We've literally fought wars over whether or not humans could own other humans, and you want to compress people down to files that could be stored in a USB thumb drive in someone's pocket? Like I said, I really don't think people who are in favor of this have thought through it.
Say you learn the feat was done using some clever use of mechanical 3D tracing or casting and chemicals that rapidly dissolve the rock and took no effort at all just knowledge of the trick. Now you would no longer be awestruck? Value for you is in the difficulty not the result?
Btw: Highly recommend “Tim's Vermeer” documentary about old mechanical art technique being reverse engineered:
https://youtu.be/WPL7D0Ha1kQ
> If you believe human produced art is valuable then you should care about verifying whether or not a human actually produced it.
Do you not question whether the enormous amount of time and effort various historical works cost was well spent? What if that time and effort was instead spent researching something useful? Does the principle of compound interest not apply to useful knowledge? What happens with compound interest over long time scales? What might our lives be today if instead of placing value on paintings / carvings / etc those before us placed more value on discovery and preservation of useful knowledge?
> This was a scandal precisely because people value the human element of chess.
It was a scandal because many use costly signals (ability to play sports / games or create or acquire stuff like “art”) to rank each other in hierarchies. What matters is the ranking. If the result mattered, anything that improves the result would be welcome, not rejected as “cheating”. Are science research / publications such an activity? For some, yes. For others, no. How do you see it?
> Just like the author of the article didn't enjoy having her work credited to a chatbot, Niemann probably didn't enjoy having his work credited to a chessbot (if he's indeed innocent).
AI assisted writing when it looks like AI assisted writing is often “empty” -- it has the right look but lacks substance. If the author of the article was told her work looked like a high schooler did it that also may have upset her.
If instead the author was told it was the work of a genius and not hers that may actually be accepted as a compliment -- if she maintains that high quality in the future what else can that be but an honest compliment on the quality of her work?
>> When you are unwell do you seek medicine? What does medicine say you are? Are you not a biochemical machine?
> I'm not sure what this passage accomplishes besides a redefinition of terms.
You said above: “I'm legitimately curious about how you see the world.” The passage above reveals how I see the world. Many see a sharp difference between “human” and “machine” yet the medicine we rely on assumes we are machines. I think many know this but do not realize the implications. To think about it can be uncomfortable.
>> Today our minds exist in one form. In the future, might our minds exist in other forms? If you had the power to upgrade various parts of yourself with better parts would you reject this?
> No, I'm not a transhumanist. I believe in using technology to help people with differing abilities (e.g. I'm fine with cochlear implants), but I'm not planning on amputating my limbs to replace them with robotic prosthetics.
Your attitude I suspect is because you do not see you already are upgraded from what you would be otherwise. Your mind has been upgraded with language and is full of useful concepts and techniques that are not your own. To aid communication and memory you rely on speech and writing for information. You are surrounded by technology that upgrades you (and your life) but it is invisible to you and you do not think about it much.