News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Loss of Things I Took for Granted by happytiger on Sunday February 11, 2024 @03:17PM (#39338241)
I think this professor has lot the plot by pinning this most recent decline on COVID and whatnot. This has been a much longer decline.

The pandemic and social media on phones are not the reason long form content is dying, though if one of those is to bear responsibility it would be social media. But it’s the death of individual passion in the teaching professions at the lower grade levels that is the direct result of common core that has a major, ongoing role in the disengagement of students from school.

It’s remarkable to sit and work with my teenagers on their homework these days. Almost all of their assignments are readily referenced online in common flash cards and study guides, and so much of the homework is droll repetition. But what strikes me is that there is no relief like there was in my time. There is no “now read chapters 3-7 of this book” in any of her homework. The passages, when there is reading, is assigned by packet and accompanied by some packaged lesson that requires you to fill in the blanks on the point of the reading, it’s key characters, and it’s learned themes and elements. It is perfect educational material put together by panels of experts and crafted to achieve the highest standardized level of understanding for most students.

And it’s incredibly, sincerely uninspiring and frequently boring.

I often spend time with my kids talking to them about subjects like ancient history, philosophy, writing, poetry, math and science in ways that are stimulating and it’s a constant refrain, “I wish school were this interesting.” We pick a theme a few times a week for dinner and have discussions with friends and family on that subject. Recently this has included subjects like demographics, geology, quantum mechanics, deep space research, sustainable energy, etc. Anyone can pick the subject.

School fails to be interesting, and we are in one of the better schools in our area. The kids are bored to tears and the format of school is incredibly unpleasant for kids that actually want to learn. This school won’t even let the kids take college classes and apply them, despite being less than five minutes from a UC and 20 minutes from a junior college. They can’t give me a good explanation as to why: they just say it’s against their policy.

So, we do our best to keep kids interested in reading and learning, but it’s fighting against their mandatory education to do so. And I really think the school, despite their best efforts, is failing these kids.

And I blame common core. More than anything else. When I sit down with teachers the better of them confide sometimes that they are really not happy with how they have to teach, but they have to teach that way and have little flexibility in customizing things in their classrooms.

They have become “presenters” of material developed far away in academic laboratories, and while they are still teaching they are far removed from any innovation in curriculum. And without that control, they really aren’t able to overcome the gigantic bureaucracy of the educational apparatus.

Re:The Loss of Things I Took for Granted by lazyasciiart on Sunday February 11, 2024 @03:37PM (#39338435)
> But what strikes me is that there is no relief like there was in my time. There is no “now read chapters 3-7 of this book” in any of her homework

That is the most bizarre complaint I have ever heard, and it’s certainly not a restriction coming from Common Core. Consider asking the school why they aren’t expected to read books.

Re:The Loss of Things I Took for Granted by happytiger on Sunday February 11, 2024 @03:47PM (#39338531)
Oh they “read books.” They just don’t read books without weighty worksheets with “lessons” and themes discussion. The reading is always purposeful and always leads to some bloated exercise. It’s rarely just reading.
Re:The Loss of Things I Took for Granted by zoolily on Monday February 12, 2024 @04:45PM (#39350952)
Some schools really focus on teaching to the test. Since the tests the student's take require answering questions based on passages, the school requires teachers to only use similar length passwords with no context during class. Their textbook is a collection of such passages.
Re:The Loss of Things I Took for Granted by graemep on Sunday February 11, 2024 @03:40PM (#39338465)
This is not just an American problem. The same has happened in the UK, and it seems to be happening in many other places too. The problem is that the west has become addicted to beureaucratic central control and distrustful of the ability of trained professionals to do their jobs without incentives and standards.

> I often spend time with my kids talking to them about subjects like ancient history, philosophy, writing, poetry, math and science in ways that are stimulating and it’s a constant refrain, “I wish school were this interesting.”

This is why I took my kids out of school. Once you get interests started and some basic skills in place kids will largely educate themselves.

Re:The Loss of Things I Took for Granted by happytiger on Monday February 12, 2024 @12:55AM (#39341883)
What did you end up doing with your kids and what age did you part ways with the school?
Re:The Loss of Things I Took for Granted by graemep on Monday February 12, 2024 @04:53AM (#39343193)
One at 8, the other at 9, but it was a bit more complicated with the older one because we wobbled and sent her back to school.

I home educated them. We started with a focus on interesting stuff, when they were ready we started studying for GCSEs (UK exams taken in schools at 16 - roughly the same level as a high school diploma in the US) which we spread out by taking some early rather than all at once as at school. Both my daughters did/are doing very well in these. Lots of time for other interests, hobbies and socialising too.

After that back to a sixth form college (a school for 16+) to do A levels (roughly equivalent level to APs in the US). Younger one has not got to that stage yet, the older one did very well (AAA*A for anyone from the UK) and is now doing a degree apprenticeship (working while studying, gets a salary plus university fees paid) in electrical engineering.

Re:The Loss of Things I Took for Granted by silverquiet on Sunday February 11, 2024 @03:52PM (#39338564)
> We don't need no education. We don't need no thought control. No dark sarcasm in the classroom. Teacher, leave them kids alone. Hey, teacher, leave them kids alone. All in all, it's just another brick in the wall. All in all, you're just another brick in the wall.

Given that that's a Pink Floyd lyric from the 70's written by men whose education would have been WWII era, it does indeed seem like a long-running theme.

Re:The Loss of Things I Took for Granted by antod on Sunday February 11, 2024 @06:39PM (#39339958)
Not really sure it is the same theme though. The bullying belittling stifling culture of a postwar British classroom is practically the polar opposite of todays education culture.
Re:The Loss of Things I Took for Granted by silverquiet on Sunday February 11, 2024 @09:47PM (#39340843)
I got stifling, overly-regimented from the parent comment if not the bullying (at least from the teachers); I suspect you're right about that part.
Re:The Loss of Things I Took for Granted by FireBeyond on Sunday February 11, 2024 @04:20PM (#39338843)
> I think this professor has lot the plot by pinning this most recent decline on COVID and whatnot.

> death of individual passion in the teaching professions at the lower grade levels that is the direct result of common core

I'm not sure how you come to that conclusion.

The professor agrees with you, talking about Common Core in their first point, and only touching on the transient COVID decline in their second point, before circling back to phonics, Common Core, again.

Trying to categorize this article as "blaming COVID for falling reading standards" is railing against something that isn't happening: literally only one of the ten paragraphs of the article references the pandemic.

Re:The Loss of Things I Took for Granted by happytiger on Sunday February 11, 2024 @05:57PM (#39339654)
Hardly. The author establishes that reading is a challenge and then attributes it to a multitude of challenges including smartphones, COVID and “broader cultural trends over which educators have little control” and balanced literacy approaches.

I submit its common core primarily that is causing the damage.

I don’t think your criticism is on point. I may not be writing well, but I think what I’m saying is largely different and certainly more single problem oriented.

Academics LOVE to sprinkle in a little of this, and a little of that to explain the problem. But the truth is not as complicated: common core is causing a decline in educational outcomes. It’s a crap way to teach kids and it should be tossed in the bin and power given back to teachers to teach and trust put back into professionals being able to teach better than centrally budgeted bureaucracy.

I could be narrow. I could be wrong. But I don’t think I’m missing the point I’m trying to make.

Re:The Loss of Things I Took for Granted by graemep on Monday February 12, 2024 @04:55AM (#39343207)
I am a bit doubtful about phonics. Everyone in my family learned to read before we were taught at school, and we all learned using whole word teaching, not phonics. It can be turned unto a game so it is easier to get kids to enjoy it.