News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jailbreaking the Degree by Turing_Machine on Saturday May 05, 2012 @03:49PM (#3933066)
"Why am I required to finance an entire degree only to be forced to take courses that I do not value?"

Maybe a kid just out of high school isn't the best judge of what forms of knowledge have "value"?

That's not to say that higher education doesn't need reform (or quite possibly wholesale replacement). It does, desperately. I just question whether a person who (by definition) doesn't possess a certain piece of knowledge is a good judge of the value of that knowledge.

I'm put in mind of my undergrad CS degree -- lots of bitching about how the courses weren't taught in C++ (the "hot" language of the day). Some of the professors even used weird stuff like Lisp! Of course, the professors had been around long enough to see "hot" languages come and go, and were choosing a language thatillustrated the concept under discussion well (which could be Lisp, could be C, could be assembly language, depending on what it was).

Of the classmates with whom I'm still in contact, I can't think of many whose primary language for employment is C++.

Re:Jailbreaking the Degree by yummyfajitas on Saturday May 05, 2012 @03:55PM (#3933084)
Maybe a kid just out of high school isn't the best judge of what forms of knowledge have "value"?

Perhaps, but he's certainly a better judge than academics who's continued employment depends on getting him to pay for their services. At least his incentives are properly aligned.

When I was in college, my judgement was that the humanities and literature would be useless while advanced math would come in handy. Nothing has happened in the past 10 years to convince me this was incorrect.

Re:Jailbreaking the Degree by _delirium on Saturday May 05, 2012 @04:05PM (#3933116)
Judging by what electives students choose when they have the option, anything with the word "math" anywhere in the vicinity is the first thing most students would skip if they didn't have to take it! If many CS students I've known had their way, all mathematical and theoretical content would be removed from the CS curriculum, and replaced with "real-world" programming classes. Less statistics, discrete math, and computability theory; more node.js, Ruby, and advanced git.

Separately from that, on your other comment, I've run into a surprisingly large number of people whose non-technical curricula have had a strong positive impact on their technical jobs. For example, Richard Evans, the AI lead on Black & White, Sims 3, and now a new startup recently acquired by Linden Labs, has a philosophy B.A., and credits it with being core to much of his AI design (his current system is based on a logic modeled on Wittgenstein's view of social interactions).

Re:Jailbreaking the Degree by yummyfajitas on Saturday May 05, 2012 @04:49PM (#3933238)
It appears that even at the age of 18-22, Richard Evans saw the value in philosophy (as demonstrated by his choice of major).

Of the students who would choose to scrap math, how many are likely to make serious use of their math skills if forced to study math in college?

Re:Jailbreaking the Degree by Turing_Machine on Sunday May 06, 2012 @10:11AM (#3935153)
Another example: Apple's success is largely due to them caring about "fuzzy" stuff like visual appearance.

Mac OS X is essentially just *nix underneath, yet somehow AAPL has a market cap of > $500B, while Linux has approximately zero traction on the desktop (yes, I know that many here run Linux desktops, but you're outliers almost by definition).

Even if one defines "value" strictly in terms of dollars and sense, it's clear that paying attention to this stuff matters. A lot.

Re:Jailbreaking the Degree by Turing_Machine on Saturday May 05, 2012 @04:05PM (#3933117)
Others do find value in those things, you know. Maybe drawing conclusions from a sample of one isn't a good idea, either? :-)
Re:Jailbreaking the Degree by mwhite on Saturday May 05, 2012 @04:37PM (#3933209)
This assumes that higher education is front-loaded like it is today. But with more granular credentials, there's less reason for that. What if, instead, the picture was something like this excerpt from Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance, especially the paragraphs beginning with "the hypothetical student": http://www.csupomona.edu/~psbeauchamp/philosophy.html

Also, it would still be perfectly possible for recognized experts to enumerate the knowledge and experience that they think everyone who seeks to become an expert in their field should gain, it would just be up to the student to decide whether to believe them or not.